sturm liouville catalog
PDF · 61 pages · 376.1 KB
Open PDF file
A published survey paper by W.N. Everitt, written after the 2003 Geneva conference marking Sturm's bicentenary. It first summarizes Sturm-Liouville theory: differential expressions, Hilbert spaces, operators, endpoint classification, boundary conditions and the Liouville transformation. It then lists over 50 examples (Bessel, Legendre, Hermite, Jacobi, Laguerre, Heun, Mathieu, Morse and others), giving endpoint types, boundary conditions and spectra where known. Filed in Phil's Stakgold support folder as a reference.
AI-written summary; may contain errors.
Extracted text (machine-read; may contain errors)
A Catalogue of Sturm-Liouville
dierential equations
W.N. Everitt
Dedicated to all scientists who, down the long years,
have contributed to Sturm-Liouville theory.
Abstract. The idea for this catalogue follows from the conference entitled:
Bicentenaire de Charles Fran cois Sturm
held at the University of Geneva, Switzerland from 15 to 19 September 2003.
One of the main interests for this meeting involved the historical development
of the theory of Sturm-Liouville dierential equations. This theory began with
the original work of Sturm from 1829 to 1836 and was then followed by the
short but signicant joint paper of Sturm and Liouville in 1837, on second-
order linear ordinary dierential equations with an eigenvalue parameter.
The details of the early development of Sturm-Liouville theory, from
the beginnings about 1830, are given in a historical survey paper of Jesper
L utzen (1984), in which paper a complete set of references may be found to
the relevant work of both Sturm and Liouville.
The catalogue commences with sections devoted to a brief summary
of Sturm-Liouville theory including some details of dierential expressions
and equations, Hilbert function spaces, dierential operators, classication of
interval endpoints, boundary condition functions and the Liouville transform.
There follows a collection of more than 50 examples of Sturm-Liouville
dierential equations; many of these examples are connected with well-known
special functions, and with problems in mathematical physics and applied
mathematics.
For most of these examples the interval endpoints are classied within
the relevant Hilbert function space, and boundary condition functions are
given to determine the domains of the relevant dierential operators. In many
cases the spectra of these operators are given.
The author is indebted to many colleagues who have responded to re-
quests for examples and who checked successive drafts of the catalogue.
Received by the editors 20 February 2004.
1991 Mathematics Subject Classication. Primary; 34B24, 34B20, 34B30: Secondary; 34L05,
34A30, 34A25.
Key words and phrases. Sturm-Liouville dierential equations; special functions; spectral theory.
2 W.N. Everitt
Contents
1. Introduction 4
2. Notations 5
3. Sturm-Liouville dierential expressions and equations 5
4. Operator theory 6
5. Endpoint classication 7
6. Endpoint boundary condition functions 8
7. The Liouville transformation 9
8. Fourier equation 10
9. Hypergeometric equation 11
10. Kummer equation 13
11. Bessel equation 14
12. Bessel equation: Liouville form 15
13. Bessel equation: form 1 16
14. Bessel equation: form 2 16
15. Bessel equation: form 3 17
16. Bessel equation: form 4 17
17. Bessel equation: modied form 18
18. Airy equation 19
19. Legendre equation 19
20. Legendre equation: associated form 20
21. Hermite equation 21
22. Hermite equation: Liouville form 21
23. Jacobi equation 21
24. Jacobi equation: Liouville form 23
25. Jacobi function equation 24
26. Jacobi function equation: Liouville form 25
27. Laguerre equation 26
28. Laguerre equation: Liouville form 26
29. Heun equation 27
30. Whittaker equation 28
31. Lam e equation 29
32. Mathieu equation 30
33. Bailey equation 31
34. Behnke-Goerisch equation 31
35. Boyd equation 32
36. Boyd equation: regularized 32
37. Dunford-Schwartz equation 33
38. Dunford-Schwartz equation: modied 34
39. Hydrogen atom equation 35
39.1. Results for form 1 35
39.2. Results for form 2 36
40. Algebro-geometric equations 37
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 3
40.1. Algebro-geometric form 1 38
40.2. Algebro-geometric form 2 38
40.3. Algebro-geometric form 3 39
40.4. Algebro-geometric form 4 40
41. Bargmann potentials 42
42. Halvorsen equation 44
43. J orgens equation 45
44. Rellich equation 45
45. Laplace tidal wave equation 46
46. Latzko equation 47
47. Littlewood-McLeod equation 47
48. Lohner equation 48
49. Pryce-Marletta equation 48
50. Meissner equation 49
51. Morse equation 50
52. Morse rotation equation 50
53. Brusencev/Rofe-Beketov equations 51
53.1. Example 1 51
53.2. Example 2 51
54. Slavyanov equations 52
54.1. Example 1 52
54.2. Example 2 52
54.3. Example 3 52
55. Fuel cell equation 53
56. Shaw equation 53
57. Plum equation 54
58. Sears-Titchmarsh equation 54
59. Zettl equation 55
60. Remarks 56
61. Acknowledgments 56
62. The future 56
References 57
4 W.N. Everitt
1. Introduction
The idea for this paper follows from the conference entitled:
Bicentenaire de Charles Fran cois Sturm
held at the University of Geneva, Switzerland from 15 to 19 September 2003. One
of the main interests for this meeting involved the development of the theory of
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations. This theory began with the original work
of Sturm from 1829 to 1836 and then followed by the short but signicant joint
paper of Sturm and Liouville in 1837, on second-order linear ordinary dierential
equations with an eigenvalue parameter. Details for the 1837 paper is given as
reference [56] in this paper; for a complete set of historical references see the
historical survey paper [59] of L utzen.
This present catalogue of examples of Sturm-Liouville dierential equations
is based on four main sources:
1. The list of 32 examples prepared by Bailey, Everitt and Zettl in the year
2001 for the nal version of the computer program SLEIGN2; this list is
to be found within the LaTeX le xamples.tex contained in the package
associated with the publication [11, Data base le xamples.tex]; all these
32 examples are contained within this catalogue.
2. A selection from the set of 59 examples prepared by Pryce and published
in 1993 in the text [69, Appendix B.2]; see also [70].
3. A selection from the set of 217 examples prepared by Pruess, Fulton and
Xie in the report [68].
4. A selection drawn up from a general appeal, made in October 2003, for
examples but with the request relayed in the following terms; examples to
be included should satisfy one or more of the following criteria:
(i) The solutions of the dierential equation are given explicitly in terms
of special functions; see for example Abramowitz and Stegun [1], the
Erd elyi at al Bateman volumes [27], the recent text of Slavyanov and
Lay [77] and the earlier text of Bell [16].
(ii) Examples with special connections to applied mathematics and math-
ematical physics.
(iii) Examples with special connections to numerical analysis; see the work
of Zettl [81] and [82].
The overall aim was to be content with about 50 examples, as now to be seen
in the list given below.
The naming of these examples of Sturm-Liouville dierential equations is
somewhat arbitrary; where named special functions are concerned the chosen name
is clear; in certain other cases the name has been chosen to re
ect one or more of
the authors concerned.
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 5
2. Notations
The real and complex elds are represented by RandCrespectively; a general
interval ofRis represented by I; compact and open intervals of Rare represented
by [a;b] and (a;b) respectively. The prime symbol0denotes classical dierentiation
on the real line R:
Lebesgue integration on Ris denoted by L;andL1(I) denotes the Lebesgue
integration space of complex-valued functions dened on the interval I:The local
integration space L1
loc(I) is the set of all complex-valued functions on Iwhich are
Lebesgue integrable on all compact sub-intervals [ a;b]I; ifIis compact then
L1(I)L1
loc(I):
Absolute continuity, with respect to Lebesgue measure, is denoted by AC; the
space of all complex-valued functions dened on Iwhich are absolutely continuous
on all compact sub-intervals of I;is denoted by ACloc(I):
A weight function wonIis a Lebesgue measurable function w:I!R
satisfyingw(x)>0 for almost all x2I:
Given an interval Iand a weight function wthe spaceL2(I;w) is dened as
the set of all complex-valued, Lebesgue measurable functions f:I!Csuch that
Z
Ijf(x)j2w(x)dx< +1:
Taking equivalent classes into account L2(I;w) is a Hilbert function space with
inner product
(f;g)w:=Z
If(x)g(x)w(x)dxfor allf;g2L2(I;w):
3. Sturm-Liouville dierential expressions and equations
Given the interval ( a;b), then a set of Sturm-Liouville coecients fp;q;wghas to
satisfy the minimal conditions
(i)p;q;w : (a;b)!R
(ii)p 1;q;w2L1
loc(a;b)
(iii)wis a weight function on ( a;b):
Note that in general there is no sign restriction on the leading coecient p:
Given the interval ( a;b) and the set of Sturm-Liouville coecients fp;q;wg
the associated Sturm-Liouville dierential expression M(p;q)M[] is the linear
operator dened by
(i) domain D(M) :=ff: (a;b)!C:f;pf02ACloc(a;b)g
(ii)M[f](x) := (p(x)f(x)0)0+q(x)f(x) for allf2D(M)
and almost all x2(a;b):
We note that M[f]2L1
loc(I) for allf2D(M); it is shown in [64, Chapter V,
Section 17] that D(M) is dense in the Banach space L1(a;b):
6 W.N. Everitt
Given the interval ( a;b) and the set of Sturm-Liouville coecients fp;q;wg
the associated Sturm-Liouville dierential equation is the second-order linear or-
dinary dierential equation
M[y](x) (p(x)y0(x))0+q(x)y(x) =w(x)y(x) for allx2(a;b);
where2Cis a complex-valued spectral parameter.
The above minimal conditions on the set of coecients fp;q;wgimply that
the Sturm-Liouville dierential equation has a solution to any initial value problem
at a pointc2(a;b); see the existence theorem in [64, Chapter V, Section 15], i.e.
given two complex numbers ;2Cand any value of the parameter 2C;there
exists a unique solution of the dierential equation, say y(;) : (a;b)!C;with
the properties:
(i)y(;) and (py0)(;)2ACloc(a;b)
(ii)y(c;) =and (py0)(c;) =
(iii)y(x;) and (py0)(x;) are holomorphic on C:
4. Operator theory
Full details of the following quoted operator theoretic results are to be found in
[64, Chapter V, Section 17] and [34, Sections I, IV and V].
The Green's formula for the dierential expression Mis, for any compact
interval [;](a;b);
Z
n
g(x)M[f](x) f(x)M[g](x)o
dx= [f;g]() [f;g]() for allf;g2D(M);
where the symplectic form [ ;]() :D(M)D(M)(a;b)!Cis dened by
[f;g](x) :=f(x)(pg0)(x) (pf0)(x)g(x):
Incorporating now the weight function wand the Hilbert function space
L2((a;b);w);the maximal operator T1generated from Mis dened by
(i)T1:D(T1)L2((a;b);w)!L2((a;b);w)
(ii)D(T1) :=ff2D(M) :f;w 1M[f]2L2((a;b);w)g
(iii)T1f:=w 1M[f] for allf2D(T1):
We note that, from the Green's formula, the symplectic form of Mhas the
property that the following limits
[f;g](a) := lim
x!a+[f;g](x) and [f;g](b) := lim
x!b [f;g](x)
both exist and are nite in C:
The minimal operator T0generated by Mis dened by
(i)T0:D(T0)L2((a;b);w)!L2((a;b);w)
(ii)D(T0) :=ff2D(T1) : [f;g](b) = [f;g](a) = 0 for all g2D(T1)
(iii)T0f:=w 1M[f] for allf2D(T0):
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 7
With these denitions the following properties hold for T0andT1;and their
adjoint operators
(i)T0T1
(ii)T0is closed and symmetric in L2((a;b);w)
(iii)T
0=T1andT
1=T0
(iv)T1is closed in L2((a;b);w)
(v)T0has equal deciency indices ( d;d) with 0d2:
Self-adjoint extensions TofT0exist and satisfy
T0TT1
where the domain D(T) is determined, as a restriction of the domain D(T1);by
applying symmetric boundary conditions to the elements of the maximal domain
D(T1):
5. Endpoint classication
A detailed account of the classication of the endpoints aandbof the interval ( a;b);
given the coecients fp;q;wg;is provided in the SLEIGN2 paper [10, Section 4].
Here we give a shorter account to cover all the examples selected for this paper.
Given the interval ( a;b) and the coecients fp;q;wgthe endpoint ais classi-
ed, independently, as regular (notation R), limit-point (notation LP), limit-circle
(notation LC), as follows:
1. The endpoint ais R ifa2Rand forc2(a;b) the coecients satisfy
p 1;q;w2L1(a;c]
2. The endpoint ais LC ifais not R and there exist elements f;g2D(T1)
such that
[f;g](a)6= 0
3. The endpoint ais LP if for all elements f;g2D(T1)
[f;g](a) = 0:
Remark 5.1. We note
1. There is a similar classication into R, LC and LP for the endpoint bof
the interval ( a;b):
2. The classication of both endpoints aandbdepends only on the coe-
cientsfp;q;wgand not on the spectral parameter :
3. The endpoint classications for aandbare analytically connected to the
number of solutions of the Sturm-Liouville dierential equation M[y] =
wy on (a;b) in the space L2((a;b);w); see the more detailed account in
[10, Section 4].
4. For any endpoint of a Sturm-Liouville dierential expression the three
classications R, LC and LP are mutually exclusive.
8 W.N. Everitt
5. Ifais R then the classical initial value problem, see the end of Section 3
above, can be solved at this point; this property does not hold if ais LC
or LP.
6. See also the account of endpoint classication in the text [69, Chapter 7],
where the additional classication LPO is introduced, but not used in this
present account.
Remark 5.2. The LC classication at any endpoint is further divided into two
sub-cases as follows:
(i) The limit-circle non-oscillatory case (notation LCNO)
(ii) The limit-circle oscillatory case (notation LCO).
This additional classication is connected with the oscillation properties of
the solutions of the Sturm-Liouville dierential equation M[y] =wy on (a;b); for
details see [10, Section 4]. As with the initial endpoint classication this additional
sub-classication depends only on the coecients fp;q;wgand not on the spectral
parameter:
6. Endpoint boundary condition functions
We suppose given the interval ( a;b) ofRand a set of coecients fp;q;wgto create
a Sturm-Liouville dierential equation, with classied endpoints.
There is a very complete account of separated and coupled boundary con-
ditions for the associated Sturm-Liouville boundary value problems, in the paper
[10, Section 5].
Here, for use in cataloguing the Sturm-Liouville examples, we give informa-
tion concerning the use of boundary condition functions at any endpoint in the
LC classication. The use of these boundary condition functions takes the same
form in both LCNO and LCO cases.
Letabe R; then a separated boundary condition at this endpoint, for a
solutionyof the Sturm-Liouville dierential equation M[y] =wy on (a;b);takes
the form, where A1;A22RwithA2
1+A2
2>0;
A1y(a) +A2(py0)(a) = 0:
Ifbis R the there is a similar form for a separated boundary condition
B1y(b) +B2(py0)(b) = 0:
Letabe LC; then a separated boundary condition at this endpoint, for a
solutiony2D(T1) of the Sturm-Liouville dierential equation M[y] =wy on
(a;b);takes the form,
A1[y;u](a) +A2[y;v](a) = 0
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 9
where
(i)A1;A22RwithA2
1+A2
2>0
(ii)u;v: (a;b)!R
(iii)u;v2D(T1)
(iv) [u;v](a)6= 0:
Such pairsfu;vgof elements from the maximal domain D(T1) always exist under
the LC classication on the endpoint a;see [10, Section 5].
Ifbis LC then there is a similar form for a separated boundary condition
involving a pairfu;vgof boundary condition functions, in general a dierent pair
from the pair required for the endpoint a;to give
B1[y;u](b) +B2[y;v](b) = 0:
For any given particular Sturm-Liouville dierential equation the search for
pairs of such boundary condition functions may start with a study of the solutions
of the dierential equation M[y] =wy on (a;b);and also with a direct search
within the elements of the maximal domain D(T1):
For the examples given in the catalogue a suitable choice of these boundary
condition functions is given, for endpoints in the LC case.
Remark 6.1. In practice it is sucient to determine the pair fu;vgin a neigh-
bourhood ( a;c] ofa;or [c;b) ofb;so that they are locally in the maximal domain
D(T1); this practice is adopted in many of the examples given in this catalogue.
7. The Liouville transformation
The named Liouville transformation, see [30, Section 4.3] and [17, Chapter 10,
Section 10] for details, of the general Sturm-Liouville dierential equation
(p(x)y0(x))0+q(x)y(x) =w(x)y(x) for allx2(a;b)
provides a means, under additional conditions on the coecients fp;q;wg;to yield
a simpler Sturm-Liouville form of the dierential equation
Y00(X) +Q(X)Y(X) =Y(X) for allX2(A;B):
The minimal additional conditions required, see [30, Section 4.3], are
(i)pandp02ACloc(a;b);andp(x)>0 for allx2(a;b)
(ii)wandw02ACloc(a;b);andw(x)>0 for allx2(a;b):
The Liouville transformation changes the variables xandytoXandYas
follows, see [30, Section 4.3]:
10 W.N. Everitt
(i) Fork2(a;b) andK2Rthe mapping X() : (a;b)!(A;B) denes a
new independent variable X() by
X(x) =l(x) :=K+Zx
kfw(t)=p(t)g1=2dtfor allx2(a;b)
A:=K Zk
afw(t)=p(t)g1=2dtandB:=K+Zb
kfw(t)=p(t)g1=2dt
where 1A < B+1; there is then an inverse mapping L() :
(A;B)!(a;b):
(ii) Dene the new dependent variable Y() by
Y(X) :=fp(x)w(x)g1=4y(x) for allx2(a;b)
:=fp(L(X))w(L(X))g1=4y(L(X)) for allX2(A;B):
The new coecient Qis given by
Q(X) =w(x) 1q(x) fw(x) 3p(x)g1=4(p(x)(fp(x)w(x)g 1=4)0)0for allx2(a;b):
An example of this Liouville transformation is worked in Section 11 for one
form of the Bessel equation.
8. Fourier equation
This is the classical Sturm-Liouville dierential equation, see [78, Chapter I, and
Chapter IV, Section 4.1],
y00(x) =y(x) for allx2( 1;+1)
with solutions
cos(xp
) and sin(xp
):
Endpoint classication in L2( 1;+1):
Endpoint Classication
1 LP
0 R
+1 LP
This is a simple constant coecient equation; for any self-adjoint bound-
ary value problem on a compact interval the eigenvalues can be characterized in
terms of the solutions of a transcendental equation involving only trigonometric
functions.
For a study of boundary value problems on the half-line [0 ;1) or the whole
line ( 1;1) see [78, Chapter IV, Section 4.1] and [2, Volume II, Appendix 2,
Section 132, Part 2].
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 11
9. Hypergeometric equation
The standard form for this dierential equation is, see [46, Chapter 4, Section
3], [80, Chapter XIV, Section 14.2], [16, Chapter 9, Section 9.2], [27, Chapter II,
Section 2.1.1], [1, Chapter 15, Section 15.5] and [78, Chapter IV, Sections 4.18 to
4.20],
z(1 z)y00(z) + [c (a+b+ 1)z]y0(z) aby(z) = 0 for all z2C
where, in general a;b;c2C:In terms of the hypergeometric function 2F1;so-
lutions of this equation are, with certain restrictions on the parameters and the
independent variable z;
2F1(a;b;c;z) andz1 c
2F1(a+ 1 c;b+ 1 c; 2 c;z):
For consideration of this hypergeometric equation in Sturm-Liouville form we
replace the variable zby the real variable x2(0;1). Thereafter, on multiplying by
the factorx(1 x)and rearranging the terms gives the Sturm-Liouville equation,
for all;2R;
x+1(1 x)+1y0(x)0=x(1 x)y(x) for allx2(0;1):
In this form the relationship between the parameters fa;b;cgandf;;gis
c=+ 1 a+b=++ 1 ab= ;
these equations can be solved for fa;b;cgin terms off;;gas in [78, Chapter
IV, Section 4.18].
Given;2Rand2Cthe solutions of this Sturm-Liouville equation can
then be represented in terms of the hypergeometric function 2F1;as above.
For the case when = 0 the general solution of this dierential equation
takes the form, for c2(0;1);
y(x) =kZx
c1
t+1(1 t)+1dt+lfor allx2(0;1)
where the numbers k;l2C:From this representation it may be shown that the
following classications, in the space L2((0;1);x(1 x));of the endpoints 0 and
1 hold:
Endpoint Parameters ; Classication
0 For 2( 1;0) and all2R R
0 For 2[0;1) and all2R LCNO
0 For 2( 1; 1][[1;1) and all2R LP
1 For 2( 1;0) and all2R R
1 For 2[0;1) and all2R LCNO
1 For 2( 1; 1][[1;1) and all2R LP
12 W.N. Everitt
For the endpoint 0 ;for2[0;1) and for all 2Rthe LCNO boundary
condition functions u;vtake the form, for all x2(0;1);
Parameter u v
= 0 1 ln( x)
2(0;1) 1x
For the endpoint 1 ;for2[0;1) and for all 2Rthe LCNO boundary
condition functions u;vtake the form, for all x2(0;1);
Parameter u v
= 0 1 ln(1 x)
2(0;1) 1 (1 x)
Another form of the hypergeometric dierential equation is obtained if in the
original equation above the independent variable zis replaced by zto give
z(1 +z)y00(z) + [c+ (a+b+ 1)z]y0(z) +aby(z) = 0 for all z2C
with general solutions
2F1(a;b;c; z) andz1 c
2F1(a+ 1 c;b+ 1 c; 2 c; z);
see the account in [78, Chapter IV, Section 4.18].
For consideration of this hypergeometric equation in Sturm-Liouville form we
replace the variable zby the real variable x2(0;1). Thereafter, on multiplying
by the factor x(1 +x)and re-arranging the terms gives the Sturm-Liouville
equation, for all ;2R;
x+1(1 +x)+1y0(x)0=x(1 +x)y(x) for allx2(0;1):
In this form the relationship between the parameters fa;b;cgandf;;gis
c=+ 1 a+b=++ 1 ab=;
these equations can be solved for fa;b;cgin terms off;;gas in [78, Chapter
IV, Section 4.18].
Given;2Rand2Cthe solutions of this Sturm-Liouville equation can
then be represented in terms of the hypergeometric function 2F1;as above.
For the case when = 0 the general solution of this dierential equation
takes the form, for c2(0;1);
y(x) =kZx
c1
t+1(1 +t)+1dt+lfor allx2(0;1)
where the numbers k;l2C:From this representation it may be shown that the
following classications, in the space L2((0;1);x(1 +x));of the endpoints 0
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 13
and +1hold:
Endpoint Parameters ; Classication
0 For 2( 1;0) and all2R R
0 For 2[0;1) and all2R LCNO
0 For 2( 1; 1][[1;1) and all2R LP
+1 For all;2R LP
For the endpoint 0 ;for2[0;1) and for all 2Rthe LCNO boundary
condition functions u;vtake the form, for all x2(0;1);
Parameter u v
= 0 1 ln( x)
2(0;1) 1x
The spectral properties of these hypergeometric Sturm-Liouville dierential
equations seem not to have been studied in detail; however there are a number of
very interesting special cases, together with their spectral properties, considered
in [78, Chapter IV, Sections 4.18 to 4.20].
10. Kummer equation
The Kummer dierential equation is a special case of the con
uent hypergeometric
dierential equation
zw00(z) + (b z)y0(z) aw(z) = 0 forz2C:
Taking the parameter b2Rto be real-valued, putting = a2C;replacing
the independent variable zbyx2R;and then writing the resulting dierential
equation in Lagrange symmetric form, gives the Sturm-Liouville example
(xbexp( x)y0(x))0=xb 1exp( x)y(x) for allx2(0;1):
Solutions of this Sturm-Liouville dierential equation are given in the form,
using the Kummer functions MandU;
M( ;b;x ) andU( ;b;x ) for allx2(0;1);b2Rand2C;
see[1, Chapter 13, Section 13.1].
Endpoint classication in L2((0;+1);xb 1exp( x)):
Endpoint Parameter bClassication
0 For b0 LP
0 For 0 <b< 1 R
0 For 1b<2 LCNO
0 For b2 LP
1 For allb2R LP
14 W.N. Everitt
For the endpoint 0 and then for b2(0;2);the LCNO boundary condition
functionsu;vtake the form, for all x2(0;1);
Parameter u v
b= 1 1 ln( x)
1<b< 2 1x1 b
See also the Laguerre dierential equation given in Section 27 below.
11. Bessel equation
The Bessel dierential equation has many dierent forms, see [79, Chapter IV], [1,
Chapters 9 and 10], [27, Volume II, Chapter VII], [46, Chapter 8], [16, Chapter
4]; see in particular [52, Part C, Section 2.162].
One elegant Sturm-Liouville form, see [33, Section 1], of this dierential equa-
tion is, where the parameter 2R;
(x2+1y0(x))0=x2+1y(x) for allx2(0;1):
Solutions of this dierential equation are, for all 2R;
x J(xp
) andx Y(xp
) for allx2(0;1)
whereJandYare the classical Bessel functions, and the power x is dened
byx := exp( ln(x)) for allx2(0;1):
For the case when = 0 the general solution of this dierential equation
takes the form, for c2(0;1);
y(x) =kZx
c1
t2+1dt+lfor allx2(0;1)
where the numbers k;l2C:From this representation it may be shown that the
following classications, in the space L2((0;1);x2+1);of the endpoints 0 and
+1hold:
Endpoint Parameter Classication
0 For 2( 1;1) LCNO
0 For 2( 1; 1][[1;1) LP
1 For all2R LP
For the endpoint 0 and then for 2( 1;1);the LCNO boundary condition
functionsu;vtake the form, for all x2(0;1);
Parameter u v
= 0 1 ln( x)
2( 1;0)[(0;1) 1x 2
As an example of the Liouville transformation, see Section 7 above, let k= 1
andK= 1 to give, for the form of the Bessel dierential equation above,
X(x) = 1 +Zx
1dt=xfor allx2(0;1);
Sturm-Liouville dierential equations 15
a computation then shows that
Q(X) = (2 1=4)x 2= (2 1=4)X 2for allX2(0;1):
Thus the Liouville form of this Bessel dierential equation is
Y00(X) + (2 1=4)X 2Y(X) =Y(X) for allX2(0;1);
where we can now take the parameter 2[0;1):
12. Bessel equation: Liouville form
In the Liouville normal form, see Sections 7 and 11 above, the Bessel dierential
equation appears as
y00(x) +
2 1=4
x 2y(x) =y(x) for allx2(0;+1);
with the parameter 2[0;+1); this dierential equation is extensively studied in
[78, Chapter IV, Sections 4.8 to 4.15]; see also [2, Volume II, Appendix 2, Section
132, Part 5]. In this form the equation has solutions
x1=2J(xp
) andx1=2Y(xp
):
Endpoint classication in L2(0;+1):
Endpoint Parameter Classication
0 For = 1=2 R
0 For all 2[0;1) but6= 1=2 LCNO
0 For all 2[1;1) LP
+1 For all2[0;1) LP
For endpoint 0 and 2(0;1) but6= 1=2;the LCNO boundary condition
functionsu;vare determined by, for all x2(0;+1);
Parameter u v
2(0;1) but6= 1=2x+1=2x +1=2
= 0 x1=2x1=2ln(x)
(a) Problems on (0 ;1] withy(1) = 0:
For 0 <1;6=1
2: the Friedrichs case: A1 = 1;A2 = 0 yields the classical
Fourier-Bessel series; here n=j2
;nwherefj;n:n= 0;1;2;:::gare the zeros
(positive) of the Bessel function J():
For1; LP at 0 so that there is a unique boundary value problem with
n=j2
;nas before.
(b) Problems on [1 ;1) all have continuous spectrum on [0 ;1):
For Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions there are no eigenvalues.
ForA1 =A2 = 1 at 1 there is one isolated negative eigenvalue.
(c) Problems on (0 ;1) all have continuous spectrum on [0 ;1):
For1 there are no eigenvalues.
For 0 < 1 the Friedrichs case is given by A1 = 1;A2 = 0; there are no
eigenvalues.
16 W.N. Everitt
For= 0:45 andA1 = 10;A2 = 1 there is one isolated eigenvalue near to
the value 175:57:
One of the interesting features of this Liouville form of the Bessel equation
is that it is possible to choose purely imaginary values of the order of the Bessel
function solutions. If =ik;withk2R;then the Liouville form of the equation
becomes
y00(x)
k2+ 1=4
x 2y(x) =y(x) for allx2(0;+1)
with solutions
x1=2Jik(xp
) andx1=2Yik(xp
):
This dierential equation is considered below in Section 44 under the name
the Krall equation
13. Bessel equation: form 1
This special case of the Bessel equation is
y00(x) xy(x) =y(x) for allx2[0;1):
This dierential equation has explicit solutions in terms of Bessel functions of
order 1=3; see [1, Chapter 10, Section 10.4], [28, Section 3], [29, Section 4] and [78,
Chapter IV, Section 4.13].
Endpoint classication in L2(0;+1):
Endpoint Classication
0 R
+1 LP
14. Bessel equation: form 2
This special case of the Bessel equation is
(xy0(x))0=xy(x) for allx2(0;1)
with the parameters >