zamar relaxation NMR paper
PDF · 16 pages · 278.6 KB
Open PDF file
Journal article by R.C. Zamar, C.E. González and O. Mensio (Universidad Nacional de Córdoba), Brazilian Journal of Physics vol. 28 no. 4, December 1998. It covers Zeeman (T1Z) and dipolar order (T1D) relaxation measured with field cycling and the Jeener-Broekaert sequence, order fluctuations of the director, and discrepancies with weak-order theory. It is a web-downloaded copy in Phil's NMR folder.
AI-written summary; may contain errors.
Extracted text (machine-read; may contain errors)
/3/1/3
/3/1/4 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8Molecular Motions in Thermotropic Liquid CrystalsStudied b y NMR Spin/-Lattice RelaxationR/.C/. Zamar/, C/.E/. Gonz/#13 alez and O/. MensioF acultad de Matem/#13 atic a/, Astr onom /#13 /#10a y F /#13 /#10sic a/,Universidad Nacional de C/#13 or dob aCiudad Universitaria /, /5/0/0/0 C/#13 or dob a/, A r gentinaReceiv ed /2/9 Octob er/, /1/9/9/8Nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation exp erimen ts with /#0Celd cycling tec hniques pro v ed tob eav aluable to ol for studying molecular motions in liquid crystals/, allo wing a v ery broadLarmor frequency v ariation/, su/#0Ecien t to separate the co op erativ e motions from the liquidlik emolecular di/#0Busion/. In new exp erimen ts com bining NMR /#0Celd cycling with the Jeener/-Bro ek aert order/-transfer pulse sequence/, it is p ossible to measure the dip olar order relaxationtime /#28 T/1 D
/#29/, in addition to the con v en tional Zeeman relaxation time /#28 T/1 Z
/#29 in a frequencyrange of sev eral decades/. When applying this tec hnique to nematic thermotropic liquidcrystals/, T/1 D
sho w ed to dep end almost exclusiv ely on the order /#0Ductuation of the directormec hanism in the whole frequency range/. This unique c haracteristic of T/1 D
mak es dip olarorder relaxation exp erimen ts sp ecially useful for studying the frequency and temp eraturedep endence of the sp ectral prop erties of the collectiv e motions/.I In tro ductionLiquid crystal molecules when ordered in a mesophaseundergo di/#0Beren t kinds of motions/. Some of themare individual molecular motions/, lik e anisotropic ro/-tational and translational di/#0Busion/. These are liquid/-
lik e rapid random jumps whic h can b e c haracterizedwith a correlation time /#1Cc
/, generally falling in the range/1/0
/, /8/, /1/0
/, /1/1s /. There are also slo w er reorien tationalmotions in v olving a large n um b er of molecules/, thatare c haracteristic of the liquid crystalline states/. Thesecollectiv e molecular /#0Ductuations/, called or der /#0Ductua/-tions of the dir e ctor /#28OFD/#29/, are describ ed through asup erp osition of a broad sp ectrum of individual purely
dissipativ e mo des/, with relaxation times ranging from/1/0
/, /4to /1/0
/, /9s /. As a consequence of the div ersit yo fc haracteristic times of the /#0Ductuations in liquid crys/-tals/, the di/#0Beren t pro cesses are clearly visible in di/#0Ber/-en t time scales/. F or example/, in Zeeman order relax/-ation NMR exp erimen ts/, the lo cal motions dominate inhigh frequencies /#28/1/0
/6/, /1/0
/8Hz /#29 while the order /#0Ductua/-tions represen t the main mec hanism of spin relaxationin the lo w and medium ranges /#28/1/0
/3/, /1/0
/6Hz /#29/.
The NMR relaxation metho d has b een used forman yy ears for studying the complex anisotropic re/-orien tation of molecules in the liquid/-crystalline state/.The measured quan tities are spin/-lattice relaxationrates whic h dep end on the in tra/- and in ter/-molecularin teractions of the n uclear spin magnetization with lo/-cal magnetic and electric /#0Celds/; these /#0Celds b eing mo d/-
ulated b y the underlying molecular motions/./#5B/1 /#5DI t i sexp erimen tally observ ed that in con v en tional liquidsthe relaxation times are almost indep enden t of theLarmor frequency /. On the con trary /, in liquid crystalmesophases/, the presence of co op erativ e motions causesthe relaxation times to ha v e a mark ed frequency dep en/-dence/, sho wing usually a disp ersion of ab out t w o ordersof magnitude in the frequency range /1/0
/4to /1/0
/8Hz /.NMR studies of molecular motions in liquid crystalsare presen tly usually p erformed b y essen tially t w o dif/-feren t spin/-relaxation exp erimen ts whic h can pro vide asatisfactory n um b er of data to disen tangle the under/-lying sp ectral densities of the sup erimp osed molecular
reorien tation/: On the one hand b y com bining high/-/#0Celd/, Zeeman relaxation /#28 T/1 Z
/#29 with high/-/#0Celd dip olarand quadrup olar order relaxation /#28 T/1 D
and T/1 Q
resp ec/-
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/1/5tiv ely/#29 measuremen ts at constan t Larmor frequency /#17L
/,in
/1Ho r
/2H as a function of temp erature/./#5B/2/#5D On theother hand b y frequency dep enden t T/1 Z
studies o v er abroad Larmor frequency /, /#17/; range/, often applying fast/-/#0Celd cycling /#28F C/#29 tec hniques/./#5B/3/#5D No w/, with adequateinstrumen ts suc h frequency dep enden t measuremen tsare not necessarily restricted to T/1 Z
/, but in principleare also applicable to T/1 D
/; this ho w ev er has only b eentried rarely and not systematically /, mainly b ecause ofexp erimen tal limitations/.Due to the complexit y of the molecular motions/, andthe fact that the di/#0Busion motions mak e their maincon tribution in high frequencies/, it is di/#0Ecult to dis/-tinguish b et w een the co op erativ e and the lo cal mo/-tions from standard high /#0Celd NMR relaxation mea/-
suremen ts/. Ho w ev er/, b y com bining /#0Celd cycling datasupplemen ted with con v en tional measuremen ts /#28for thehighest frequencies/#29/, it is p ossible to co v er a broad fre/-quency range /#28/1/0
/3/, /1/0
/8Hz /#29/, allo wing to distinguish themec hanisms unam biguously /.The basic theory for explaining relaxation exp er/-imen ts relates the relaxation times with the sp ectraldensities of the lattice/; that is/, with the nonspin v ari/-ables/. The second step demands a mo del for thesp ectral densities that relates them with the particu/-
lar system /#28viscosit y /, elastic constan ts/, etc/#29 and withthe externally con trolled v ariables /#28temp erature/, fre/-quency /, orien tation/#29/. The theory of spin/-lattice re/-laxation for liquid crystals is based on the w eak/-orderassumption/,/#5B/1 /, /4/, /5/#5D that w as traditionally applied inliquids and solids/. The starting p oin t is the sto c has/-tic Liouville equation for the densit y op erator of thespin system/, whic hi s i n tegrated up to second orderin the p erturbation /#28the in teraction with the lattice/#29/.The spin system is considered as an ensem ble of iso/-lated spins/, the neigh b oring spins b eing considered asfar as they form part of the lattice/.In the calculation of the sp ectral densities of thelattice/, the molecular motions are generally mo deledb y sto c hastic Mark o vian pro cesses/. This is suitablefor liquid crystals/, b ecause of the lo w degree of p o/-sitional order of the molecular motions/. The mo delsfor rotational and traslational di/#0Busion are basically
the same as those used in liquids/, with some re/#0Cne/-
men ts to re/#0Dect the c haracteristic anisotrop y of the liq/-uid crystals/./#5B/6/, /7 /, /8/#5D The mo dels for the OFD are based
on the h ydro dynamic theory /./#5B/9 /#5D It is assumed that themolecules follo w the director dynamics/; so doing the ef/-fects of the in termolecular short range correlation areneglected/./#5B/1/0/, /1/1/#5D This approac h yields sp ectral densi/-ties prop ortional to /#17
/, /1 /= /2and /#17
/, /1for nematics /#5B/1/2 /,/1 /3 /#5Dand smectics /#5B/1/4 /,/1 /5 /#5D resp ectiv ely /. In the case of nemat/-ics/, this la w has b een con/#0Crmed b y /#0Celd cycling exp er/-imen ts of Zeeman relaxation of protons and deuteronsin n umerous nematogens/./#5B/3 /,/1 /6 /#5DI tw as observ ed thatthe OFD are dominan t in the frequency range /1/0
/3/-/5 /#02 /1/0
/5Hz/. There are also clear NMR F C examplesof b oth smectic thermotropic phases and smectic/-t yp ely otropics displa ying the men tioned linear frequencydep endence/./#5B/1/8 /, /1/9/, /2/0/, /2/1/#5DOne of the main h yp otheses of the traditional the/-ory of relaxation concerning the correlation time of the/#0Ductuations is that of the fast motion/: /#17SI
/#1Cc
/#3C /1 where/#17SI
is the c haracteristic frequency of the spin in terac/-tion /#28dip olar or quadrup olar/#29 and /#1CC
is the correlationtime of the /#0Ductuation/. A consequence of this assump/-tion is that the spin in teractions can b e neglected fromthe spin dynamics in the microscopic time scale/. /#5B/5 /#5DThough the former condition is not ful/#0Clled b y the slo w/-est comp onen ts of the OFD/, this fact do es not consti/-tute a di/#0Ecult y in high /#0Celd Zeeman order relaxation/.In these cases the picture of a single spin in teractingwith a random bath is adequate/, hence the details ofthe spin in teractions during the lifetime of the /#0Ductu/-ations can b e neglected/. The analysis of exp erimen/-tal T/1 Z
within this theoretical framew ork sho w ed to b econsisten t/. /#5B/2 /,/3 /, /2 /2 /#5DHo w ev er/, this w ould not b e the case of dip olar or/-der relaxation/, where the relaxing magnitude is thedip ole/-dip ole energy /. In fact/, recen t results of T/1 Din thermotropic nematic liquid crystals/, as a functionof the Larmor frequency in /#0Celd cycling exp erimen tsevidenced clear discrepancies with the standard w eak/-order theory /#5B/2/8/#5D/. The OFD are the leading relaxationmec hanisms ev en at high frequencies/, ha ving a largerw eigh t than the predicted b y the standard approac h/.This fact indicates the presence of additional relaxationmec hanisms/, driv en b y the OFD/, whic h are not tak enin to accoun tb y the traditional approac h/. Due to itshigher sensitivit y to the co op erativ e motions/, T/1 D
isap o w erful to ol for in v estigating sp ectral prop erties of
/3/1/6 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8h ydro dynamic /#0Ductuations in mesophases/.The p ossibilit y of measuring sev eral indep enden t re/-laxation times/, re/#0Decting di/#0Beren t features of the molec/-ular motions/, together with the existence of p o w erfulexp erimen tal tec hniques/, mak e NMR relaxation a v eryimp ortan t to ol for c haracterizing molecular motions inmesophases/.In Section /2 w e presen t a short review of the the/-oretical bac kground necessary to in terpret the exp eri/-men tal results/. Some examples illustrating the p ossibil/-ities of /#0Celd cycling NMR exp erimen ts/, in protons anddeuterons/, are sho wn in Section /3/. This selection do esnot attempt to b e a review of this v ast /#0Celd/. Finallyin Section /4 some new/, con tro v ersial results on dip olarorder relaxation are presen ted/, and discussed in termsof the existen t theory /, together with an analysis of ap ossible w a y to understand the disagreemen t/.II Theoretical bac kgroundNMR relaxation exp erimen ts deal with the n uclear spindegrees of freedom and pro vide information on the hostlattice through the time ev olution of the spin system/.It is usual to think on the spin system as a thermo dy/-
namic system in con tact with a reserv oir /#28the lattice/#29ha ving a h uge n um b er of degrees of freedom/. In a t yp/-ical exp erimen t/, energy in the form of radio frequencypulses/, is deliv ered to the spins in order to prepare it
/#28in the quan tum mec hanical sense/#29/. The system is thenallo w ed to dev elop in con tact with the lattice duringthe ev olution p erio d/. The last step of the exp erimen ti sjust to pic k up the result of the ev olution/. The reco v/-ery of the equilibrium state o ccurs with a c haracteristictime called spin/-relaxation time/, conditioned b y the ef/-/#0Cciency of the spin/-lattice relaxation mec hanisms/.The Hamiltonia n describing the spin system and thelattice isH /= HS
/+ HL
/+ HSL
/; /#28/1/#29HS
and HL
are the spin and the lattice Hamiltoni/-ans resp ectiv ely /, and HSL
represen ts the spin/-latticein teraction/./#5B/1 /#5D The spin Hamiltonian con tains the en/-ergy of in teraction with the external magnetic /#0Celd/#28Zeeman energy/#29 and the a v erage energy of the spinin teractions/. F or the usually a v ailable magnetic /#0Celds/,the principal spin in teractions are the dip ole/-dip ole andquadrup olar energies/. F or example/, in the case of thedip olar in teraction b et w een lik e spins the spin Hamil/-tonian is/:HS
/= HZ
/+HSI
withHZ
/= /, /#0D /~ H/0
Pj
Ijz
/; andHSI
/=
/1/2
Plk
Pq
A
qlk
F
qlk
/;
/#28/2/#29/#0D is the gyromagnetic ratio and the upp er bar meansa v erage o v er the lattice ensem ble/. A
qlk
and F
qlk
are spinand lattice op erators asso ciated to the dip olar spin in/-teraction/:cA
/0lk
/= /, /#0D /~ f/, I
zl
I
zk
/+
/1/4
/#28 I
/+l
I
/,k
/+ I
/+k
I
/,l
/#29 g F
/0lk
/=
/1r
/3lk
/#28/1 /, /3 cos
/2/#12lk
/#29A
/#06 /1lk
/= /,
/3/2
/#0D /~ /#28 I
zl
I
/#06k
/+ I
/#06l
I
zk
/#29 F
/#06 /1lk
/=
/1r
/3lk
sin /#12lk
cos /#12lk
e
/#06 i/#1ElkA
/#06 /2lk
/= /,
/3/4
/#0D /~ I
/#06l
I
/#06k
/; F
/#06 /2lk
/=
/1r
/3lk
sin
/2/#12lk
e
/#06 /2 i/#1Elk/:
/#28/3/#29d/#12 and /#1E are the spherical angular co ordinates of the in/-tern uclear v ector rlk
resp ect to a frame whose z /-axis isparallel to the magnetic /#0Celd H/0
/. In the quadrup olarcase the in teraction is that of the n uclear quadrup olarmomen t with the electric /#0Celd gradien t of the electronicc harge distribution/. The angular dep endence refers tothe orien tation of the principal axis system of the elec/-tric /#0Celd gradien t tensor with resp ect to the lab oratoryframe/./#5B/2 /#5D
The spin/-lattice in teraction Hamiltonian re/#0Dects the/#0Ductuations of the spin in teractions caused b y the lat/-tice motions/. F or example/, for dip olar in teraction/:HSL
/=/#01 HD
/=
/1/2
Plk
Pq /=/0 /#06 /1 /#06 /2
A
qlk
/#01 F
qlk
/;/#28/4/#29where/: /#01 F
qlk
/#28 t /#29 /#11 F
qlk
/#28 t /#29 /, F
qlk
/:The densit y op erator of the whole system /#28spins and
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/1/7lattice/#29 satis/#0Ces the Liouville equationd/#1Adt
/= /,
i/~
/#5B H /;/#1A /#5D /: /#28/5/#29In NMR exp erimen ts only the spin system is detected/,therefore/, the relev an t statistical op erator for calcu/-lating the time ev olution of the observ ables asso ci/-ated to the spin system is the r e duc e d densit y op erator/#1B /#11 TrL
f /#1A g /, where TrL
stands for the trace o v er thelattice v ariables/. The time ev olution of this op erator isdescrib ed b y /#5B/2/3 /#5Dd/#1Bdt
/= /,
i/~
TrL
/#5B H /;/#1A /#5D /: /#28/6/#29A t this p oin tt w o basic assumptions are made/: i /#29The coupling b et w een the spin system and the lattice
is w eak enough for allo wing to factorize the total den/-sit y op erator in the second mem b er of Eq/./#28/7/#29 as a /#0Crstappro ximation/.ii /#29 The lattice is considered as a quan tum dissipa/-tiv e system ha ving so man y degrees of freedom thatdissipates the energy transferred b y the spins in a shorttime of the order of the lattice correlation time/, whic his m uc h shorter than the in terv al where the observ edmagnitude v aries appreciably /. This means that the lat/-tice can b e considered alw a ys at the equilibrium state/.Under these conditions/, the master equation in the in/-teraction picture adopts the t ypical form of Mark o vianpro cesses/:
d/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29dt
dep ends only on /#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29/, with time in/-dep enden t co e/#0Ecien ts/:/#5B/1/, /2/3 /#5Dcd/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29dt
/= /, /~
/, /2
Z/1/0
dt
/0TrL
/#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t /#29 /; /#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t
/0/#29 /;/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29 /#1AL
/#28/0/#29/#5D/#5D /; /#28/7/#29where /#1AL
/#28/0/#29 is the equilibrium canonical densit y op erator of the lattice and /`/*/' indicates that op erators are expressedin the in teraction picture/.Eq/./#28/7/#29 can b e rewritten in a more con v enien t form for studying longitudinal relaxation/. F ollo wing Abragam /#5B/1 /#5Dd/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29dt
/= /,
/~
/, /2/2
TrL
nR/1/,/1
dt
/0/#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t /#29 /; /#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t
/0/#29 /;/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29/#5D/#5D /#1AL
/#28/0/#29 /,/,
R/1/,/1
dt
/0/#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t
/0/#29 /;/#1AL
/#28/0/#29/#5D /#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29 H
/#03SL
/#28 t /#29/+/+ H
/#03SL
/#28 t /#29 /#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29
R/1/,/1
dt
/0/#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t
/0/#29 /;/#1AL
/#28/0/#29/#5D
o/:
/#28/8/#29dThe /#0Crst term has the structure of an ensem ble a v er/-age o v er the the lattice v ariables and coincides formallywith the semiclassical master equation as deduced fromthe sto c hastic Liouville equation/. The traditional w eakorder master equation is obtained from Eq/./#28/8/#29 b y as/-suming high lattice temp erature /#28 h/#17 /=KB
T /#1C /1/#29/, andthat the spin system is nev er v ery remote from a
state with equal p opulations of all spin energy lev els/#28 /#1B
/#03/' I /= A /, I b eing the iden tit y op erator in the Hilb ertspace of the spin system and A b eing the n um be r o fdegrees of freedom of the spin system/#29/./#5B/1 /,/2 /4 /#5D The re/-sulting equation coincides essen tially with the /#0Crst termof Eq/./#28/8/#29 but including the correct stationary state/:cd/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29dt
/= /,
/~
/, /2/2
Z/1/,/1
dt
/0/#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t /#29 /; /#5B H
/#03SL
/#28 t
/0/#29 /;/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29 /, /#1B/0
/#5D /: /#28/9/#29d
/3/1/8 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8This k ey equation allo ws the calculation of thetime dep endence of an y observ able of the spin systemd hO
/#03idt
/= Trs
/#5B
d/#1B
/#03/#28 t /#29dt
O
/#03/#28 t /#29/#5D/. It describ es the irrev ersibleev olution of a macroscopic quan tit y and allo ws the cal/-culation of the transp ort co e/#0Ecien ts/. In NMR relax/-ation suc h co e/#0Ecien ts are the relaxation times/; theycan b e related to the sp ectral densities/, that is theF ourier transforms of the time correlation functions ofthe /#0Ductuating lattice op erators/, ev aluated at the Lar/-mor frequency /, /#17 /.F or example/, the time ev olution ofthe z /-comp onen t of the magnetization /#28parallel to theexternal /#0Celd/#29/, due to dip olar coupling in a system of
t w o lik e spins isddt
h Iz
/+ I
/0z
i /=
/1T/1 Z
fh Iz
/+ I
/0z
i/, h Iz
/+ I
/0z
ieq uil
g /;
whereT
/, /1/1 Z
/=
/9/8
/#0D
/4/~
/2f J
/1/#28 /! /#29/+ J
/2/#28/2 /! /#29 g /#28/1/0/#29is the Zeeman order relaxation time and /! /=/2 /#19/#17 /. Thesp ectral densities J
q/#28 /! /#29 are de/#0Cned asJ
q/#28 /! /#29/=
Z/1/,/1
F
qF
/, q/#28 t /#29 exp
i q/!tdt /:In T able /1 w e summarize the standard theoreticalexpressions for the most commonly measured relaxationtimes/. There w e sho w the observ able corresp onding toeac h case/, the kind of /#0Ductuations resp onsible for dis/-sipating the initial condition/, and the relaxation timesform ulae in terms of the sp ectral densities/. These ex/-pressions are the outcome of the traditional w eak ordertheory /#5BEq/./#28/9/#29/#5D/.cT able I/: Relaxation rates within the w eak order theory of spin relaxation/. In the three /#0Crst cases the observ able isthe energy of in teraction of isolated spins/. F or T
/, /1/1 D
the observ able is the secular dip ole/-dip ole energy /, and a mo delof isolated spin pairs is assumed/. Here CD
/=
/9/8
/#0D
/4/~
/2/, CQ
/=
/3/2
/#10e
/2qQ/~
/#11/2/, and Q is the n uclear quadrup ole momen t/.Observ able Relaxation time SL in teraction Refs /:Ph Izj
i proton Zeeman order T
/, /1/1 Z
/= CD
Plk
J
/#28/1/#29lk
/#28 /! /#29/+ J
/#28/2/#29lk
/#28/2 /! /#29 dip olar /#5B/1/, /4/#5Dh Iz
i deut/. Zeeman order T
/, /1/1 Z
/= CQ
/#02J
/#28/1/#29/#28 /! /#29/+ /4 J
/#28/2/#29/#28/2 /! /#29
/#03quadrup olar /#5B/2 /#5Dh H
/0Q
i quadrup olar order T
/, /1/1 Q
/=/3 CQ
J
/#28/1/#29/#28 /! /#29 quadrup olar /#5B/2/5 /, /2/6/#5Dh H
/0D
i dip olar order T
/, /1/1 D
/=/3 CD
J
/#28/1/#29/#28 /! /#29 dip olar /#5B/3/3 /, /5/0/#5DdThe form ula for proton Zeeman relaxation is a di/-rect generalization of Eq/./#28/1/0/#29 for the case of man y non/-in teracting spins /#5B/1 /#5D/. The deuteron Zeeman relaxationtime describ es the relaxation of the magnetization of aquadrup olar n ucleus due to /#0Ductuations of the electric/#0Celd gradien t of the c hemical b ond b earing the reso/-nan tn ucleus/. This is a single/-spin description/, and isadequate when the dip olar in teraction with neigh b or/-ing spins can b e neglected/./#5B/2 /#5D T/1 Q
and T/1 D
refer to therelaxation of quadrup olar or dip olar order created b yapulse sequence /#28Jeener/-Bro ek aer t exp erimen t /#5B/2/7 /#5D/#29 thattransfers the magnetic Zeeman order to the quadrup o/-lar or dip olar reserv oirs/. The three /#0Crst lines of T able /1represen t situations whic h can b e adequately describ edb y a picture of isolated spins/, acted on b y a random p er/-turbation coming from the neigh b oring spins/. On the
con trary /, the case of dip olar order relaxation is basi/-cally di/#0Beren t b ecause in this case the observ able hH
/0D
iin v olv es the in teractions among man y spins/. Here w eincluded the t w o/-spin form ula for T/1 D
rep orted in theliterature/. Nev ertheless/, a recen t /#0Celd cycling studysho w ed that this form ula is incomplete for describingthe exp erimen tal data in nematics /#5B/2/8 /, /2/9/, /3/0 /#5D /#28see Sec/-tion IV/#29/.III ApplicationsA/. The Field/-Cycling T ec hniqueMeasuremen ts of the relaxation times /#28 T/1 Z
/, T/1 D
orT/1 Q
/#29 pro vide/, in principle/, a means of determining thesp ectral densities of the molecular motions/. Accord/-ing to T able I/, b y com bining data of di/#0Beren t relax/-
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/1/9ation exp erimen ts/, it is p ossible to determine J
/1/#28 /#17 /#29and J
/2/#28 /#17 /#29 separately /./#5B/2/8 /#5D Then/, the comparison of theirdep endence with the magnetic /#0Celd and temp eraturewith the theoretically predicted dep endence for the in/-
v olv ed molecular /#0Ductuations/, allo ws to obtain informa/-tion ab out the di/#0Beren t motional pro cesses in v olv ed/.F or example/, con v en tional NMR temp erature dep en/-den t exp erimen ts of Zeeman and quadrup olar align/-men t relaxation in selectiv ely deuterated liquid crystals/,allo wt o c haracterize in tramolecular motions and alsogiv e some consisten t information ab out the order /#0Duc/-tuations/. /#5B/3/1 /,/3 /2 /#5D The dynamics of the aliphatic c hainsin nematics w as studied in detail b y using this metho dand comparing with theoretical mo del for molecularp oten tials/./#5B/2 /, /3/3/#5DHo w ev er/, since the con v en tional NMR studies pro/-vide the T/1 Z
pro/#0Cle only in a rather narro w sp ectro/-scopic windo w/, the /#0Ctting of data with form ula fromT able I and Eq/./#28/1/1/#29 b ecomes am biguous and it is dif/-/#0Ccult to separate the con tribution from the di/#0Beren trelaxation mec hanisms/. Due to this w eakness/, someearly high frequency measuremen ts /#5B/3/4 /, /3/5/, /3/6/#5D b eliev edto ha v e found the theoretically predicted square ro otfrequency dep endence c haracteristic of the OFD in ne/-matics /#5Bsee Eq/. /#28/1/2/#5D/.This apparen t result is incorrect b ecause the re/-p orted /#0Cts in the MHz range do not coincide with sub/-sequen tl o w frequency mesuremen ts when extrap olated/.The mistak em a y b e originated in the fact that theother relaxation mec hanisms p ossess a narro w rangewhere the corresp onding sp ectral densities can b e ap/-pro ximated b y J /#28 /#17 /#29/= a/#17
/, /1 /= /2/+ b /.A more comprehensiv e relaxometric study can b ep erformed b y extending the measuremen ts to the kHzdomain/. Ho w ev er/, standard NMR sp ectrometers can/-not p erform lo w frequency measuremen ts/, b ecause thesignal amplitude strongly decreases at lo w er externalmagnetic /#0Celds/. The adequate exp erimen tal metho d tosolv e this di/#0Ecult y is the /#0Celd/-cycling tec hnique/, sinceit allo ws to enlarge the range of the motional sp ectrumscanned b y longitudinal spin/-lattice relaxation exp eri/-men ts/, b y man y orders of magnitude/. Details of the ba/-sic principles of the tec hnique can b e found in Reference/#5B/3/#5D and /#5B/3/7/#5D In few w ords/, the metho d is based on theconcept of adiabatic demagnetization/. The spin systemis p olarized at high /#0Celds /#28 frequency in the MHz re/-
gion/#29/. Then/, the external /#0Celd is adiabatically switc hedto a selectable lo w er lev el/. The spin system ev olv es /#28re/-laxes/#29 under these conditions/, and after a giv en in terv althe /#0Celd is again adiabatically switc hed to its originalv alue/, where the magnetization is detected b y applyinga radiofrequency pulse /#28see Fig/. /1a/#29/. So doing allo wsto deal with a MHz qualit y signal but no wk eeping theinformation of the spin/-lattice relaxation at lo w /#0Celd/.
Figure /1/. a/#29 T ypical mo dulation of the Zeeman /#0Celd in a/#0Celd cycling NMR exp erimen t/. b/#29 Sc heme of the Jeener/-Bro ek aert pulse sequence com bined with a /#0Celd cycling/.During the p olarization p erio d t w o phase shifted pulses areapplied to create dip olar order/. Subsequen tly the spin sys/-tem ev olv es in a di/#0Beren t magnetic /#0Celd during the relax/-ation p erio d/. Finally /, after switc hing bac k the Zeeman /#0Celdto the detection v alue HD
/, a read pulse is applied and thedip olar signal is acquired/.B/. Selected Exp erimen tsA systematic study of the Larmor frequency dep en/-dence of T/1 Z
in thermotropic liquid crystals w as car/-ried out mainly b y the group of F/. Noac k /#28Univ ersitatStuttgart/#29/. P articularly /, the nematic phase has b eenextensiv ely studied/. /#5B/3 /, /3/8/, /3/9/, /4/0/#5DAn illustrativ e example is the textb o ok comp oundPA A /#28/4/,/4/' /- dimeth ylo xy azo xyb enzene/#29/. Fig/. /2 sho wsthe proton relaxation disp ersion T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 for nematicand isotropic phases/. The isotropic phase sho ws thec haracteristic b eha vior of common liquids/. On thecon trary /, relaxation in the nematic phase exhibits aw ell dev elop ed /#17
/1 /= /2dep endence in the frequency range
/3/2/0 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8/1/0
/3/, /1/0
/6Hz /, rev ealing the o ccurrence of order /#0Ductua/-tions of the director/.
Figure /2/. Proton relaxation disp ersion T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 for nematicand isotropic P AA/. The nematic phase sho ws a square ro otfrequency dep endence/, that is absen t in the isotropic phase/.The solid lines are mo del /#0Cts includin g OFD/, self/-di/#0Busion/,molecular rotation and a lo w frequency cut/-o/#0B/. Data fromRef/./3/9/.T ypically /, in thermotropic liquid crystals the sev/-eral mec hanisms con tributing to spin relaxation can b econsidered as statistically indep enden t pro cesses/. Un/-der this condition/, the sp ectral densities can b e cal/-
culated as a sum of separate con tributions from themolecular rotational tum bling /#28R OT/#29/, traslational self/-di/#0Busion /#28SD/#29 /#28lo cal motions/#29 and the OFD/:J
q/#28 /#17 /#29/= J
qOF D
/#28 /#17 /#29/+ J
qSD
/#28 /#17 /#29/+ J
qRO T
/#28 /#17 /#29 /: /#28/1/1/#29The three sp ectral densities are/:/1/. Or der Fluctuations of the Dir e ctor/1a/. Nematics /#5B/1/2 /,/1 /3 /#5DJ
/1OF D
/#28 /#17 /#29/= A/#17
/, /1 /= /2/; /#28/1/2/#29withA /=
kB
TS
/2/2 /#19K r
/6
/#12K/#11
/+ D
/#13/, /1 /= /2/#28/3 cos
/2/#0B /, /1/#29
/2/4
/; /#28/1/3/#29where kB
is the Boltzmann constan t/, K is the a v er/-age F rank constan t/, /#11 is the viscosit y /, r the in terprotondistance and /#0B stands for the angle b et w een the in ter/-n uclear v ector and the molecular axis/./1b/. Sme ctics /#5B/1/4 /#5DJ
/1OF D
/#28 /#17 /#29/= B/#17
/, /1/; /#28/1/4/#29
withB /=
kB
TS
/2/#19K/1/1
/#18r
/6
/#28/3 cos
/2/#0B /, /1/#29
/2/4
/;where K/1/1
is the spla y elastic constan t /#28assumed to b eequal to the t wist constan t K/2/2
/#29 and /#18 is the coher/-ence length in the direction p erp endicular to the smec/-
tic la y ers/. The sp ectral densit y J
/2OF D
is assumed to b enegligibly in the small amplitude appro ximation/. /#5B/1/0 /#5D/2/. R otation /#5B/2/#5DJ
qRO T
/#28 /#17 /#29/=
/3/2
BR
/#1CR
q
/2/1/+ /#28 q/#19/#17 /#1C/?
/#29
/2where BR
is a relaxation amplitude factor dep endingon b oth bulk and molecular prop erties and /#1CR
is thecorrelation time of the reorien tation ab out the shortmolecular axes/./3/. Self/-Di/#0Busion /#5B/6 /#5DJ
qSD
/#28 /#17 /#29/=
C/#1CD
q
/2x
/4
/#5B u /+/#28 u sin x /+ v cos x /#29 e
/, x/#5Dwhere u /=
/,x/2
/,
/1x
/#01/;v /=
/,x/2
/+
/1x
/+/2
/#01/; and x /#11pq/#19/#17 /#1CD
/, C is the di/#0Busion amplitude factor/, and /#1CDis the correlation time of the translational molecularjump/.The mo dels describ ed ab o v e allo w a quan titativ edescription of relaxation disp ersion/. As an example/,Fig/. /3 sho ws the T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 pro/#0Cle for the nematic HpAB/#28/4/,/4/' /-bis/-hept ylo xy azo xy/-b enzene/#29 with the con tribu/-tions from the di/#0Beren t relaxation mec hanisms/./#5B/2/8 /#5D Thisis a c haracteristic pro/#0Cle of thermotropic nematics/. Itis clear again that the OFD dominate the relaxation in
the KHz regime/. F or the /#0Cttings it w as also consideredal o w frequency cut/-o/#0B /#17c
as predicted b y R/. Blinc/./#5B/4/1 /#5D
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/2/1
Figure /3/. Proton relaxation of the Zeeman and the dip o/-lar order in nematic HpAB sho wing the three individualcon tributions for T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 together with the rotation termfor T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29 /#28self/-di/#0Busion do es not con tribute to dip olar re/-laxation /-see text/#29/. Rotations con tributes appreciably toZeeman order relaxation in the MH z regime/, but are neg/-ligible for dip olar order relaxation in all measured range/.Data from Ref/./2/8/.The F C measuremen ts allo w ed to o v ercome someam biguities in the ev aluation of the parameters in v olv edin the /#0Cttings/, namely A /, B /, BR
/, C /, /#17c
/, /#1CR
/, /#1CD
/.P artic/-ularly /, the exp erimen tal amplitude factor A can b e ob/-tained with go o d precision/. The consistency of the /#0Ct/-
tings is supp orted b y reasonable magnitudes of the pa/-rameters and systematic parallels for all the measuredcomp ounds/. F or instance/, the /#0Ctted amplitude factorsA ha v e a go o d agreemen t with the theoretical predic/-tion from Eq/./#28/1/3/#29/, for man y studied comp ounds/./#5B/3 /, /4/2/#5DMoreo v er/, the obtained v alues for the self/-di/#0Busioncorrelation time /#1CD
can b e compared with di/#0Busionconstan t measuremen ts b y means of a sp ecial com bi/-nation of NMR Field/-Cycling with pulsed /#0Celd gradi/-en ts tec hniques/./#5B/4/3/#5D Assuming the relation /#5B/6 /#5D /#1CD
/=
b
/2/6 D/#28with the distance of closest proton approac h for di/#0Bu/-sion and D /=
/1/3
/#28 Dk
/+/2 D/?
/#29 an e/#0Bectiv e di/#0Busion con/-stan t/#29/, the calculated correlation times coincide in orderof magnitudes with the /#0Ctting parameters/. /#5B/4/3 /#5DAnother in teresting feature arising from F C mea/-suremen ts is the o ccurrence of the lo w frequency cut/-o/#0B t ypically ab out few KHz /#28 Fig/. /3/#29/. A t the presen t/,t w o p ossible explanations for this b eha vior ha v e b eensuggested/: the /#0Crst one states that/, since the minim um/#0Celd whic h could giv e rise to Zeeman order cannot b eless than the lo cal /#0Celds pro duced b y the neigh b oringspins/, it w ould b e exp ectable that for frequencies of the
order of few KHz /, T/1 Z
b ecame frequency indep enden t/;the second one refers to the /#0Cniteness of the nematicorder correlation length/, /#5B/4/1 /#5D /#18 /, due to the presence ofdisclinations and other defects/. In suc h a case only or/-der /#0Ductuations with a w a v elength smaller than /#18 cantak e place/, giving rise to a minim um cut/-o/#0B frequency /,through the /`disp ersion relation/'/#17c
/=
/2 /#19K/#11/#18
/2
/; /#28/1/5/#29where K is the e/#0Bectiv e elastic constan t and /#11 is thee/#0Bectiv e viscosit y /. Although most w ork ers fa v or thesecond h yp othesis/, a /#0Cnal exp erimen tal con/#0Crmation isstill lac king and the sub ject is no w ada ys b eing in v esti/-gated theoretically and exp erimen tally /./#5B/4/4 /#5DThe thermotropic smectic mesophase has not b eenstudied so extensiv ely as the nematic one/. Nev ertheless/,the a v ailable exp erimen tal results sho w clearly the pres/-ence of collectiv e motions/. /#5B/1/9 /,/4 /5 /#5D Fig/. /4 sho ws the T/1 Zpro/#0Cle for TBBA in the smectic A phase/./#5B/1/9/#5D It can b eappreciated the predicted /#17
/1/-la w for order /#0Ductuationswithin a smectic la y er /#5BEq/./#28/1/4/#29/#5D/. This linear dep endenceis eviden t in the frequency range /1/0
/3/, /1/0
/5Hz /, sho wingagain that the OFD are the dominan t relaxation mec h/-anism for the Zeeman order only at lo w Larmor fre/-quencies/. Tw o additional relaxation mec hanisms /#28self/-di/#0Busion and anisotropic rotations/#29 are necessary to de/-
scrib e the exp erimen tal results/.Recen tly /, other w ork ers /#5B/4/6 /#5Dh a v e measured a tran/-sition from /#17
/1to /#17
/1 /= /2in the T/1 Z
frequency dep endenceof smectic /8CB /#28/4/- cy ano/-/4/' /-/8/-alkylbiphen yl/#29 at /2/3
oK/,i/:e/: close to the smectic A/-nematic transition/. A similarresult w as observ ed in the smectic HpAB at /8/2
oK/, butno w far from the transition/. /#5B/4/7 /#5D Conceiv ably /, this fea/-ture w as not detected in earlier measuremen ts due tothe lo w densit y of exp erimen tal p oin ts/. A t the presen t/,it is not clear if this is a pretransitional e/#0Bect or if it re/-
/#0Dects an in trinsic c haracteristic of the collectiv e /#0Ductu/-ations in the smectic phase/. Eviden tly /, more systematicmeasuremen ts are needed/.
/3/2/2 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8
Figure /4/. Proton spin relaxation disp ersion/, T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29/, forTBBA in smectic A and smectic C phases/. The solid lineis the /#0Ct according to T able I and Eq/. /#28/1/1/#29 includin g againOFD/, molecular rotations and self/-di/#0Busion/. Data from Ref/./1/9/.
Figure /5/. Proton relaxation disp ersion T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 for the micel/-lar/, hexagonal/, cubic and lamellar phase of a ly otropic p otas/-sium laurate/-D/2
O mixtures/. The micellar and the hexago/-nal system sho w the /#17
/1dep endence t ypical of smectics/. Thelinear pro/#0Cle is absen t in the isotropic phases/. Data fromRefs/. /3/,/1/8/.The linear frequency dep endence is b etter dev elop edin ly otropic liquid crystals/. As p oin ted b y Kuhner etal /, /#5B/4/8 /#5D this feature is exp ectable b ecause the smec/-tic t yp e la y ers are almost decoupled b y the w ater in/-terface/. In this w a y /, eac h one constitutes basically at w o/-dimensional system/. An example are lamellar orhexagonal p otassium laurate/-w ater mixtures /#28see Fig/.
/5/#29/, where the /#17
/1/-la w is observ ed appro ximately in therange /1/0
/3/, /1/0
/5Hz /.An indep enden t exp erimen t pro viding additionalexp erimen tal evidence of the presence of collectiv e /#0Duc/-tuations in nematics are NMR /#0Celd/-cycling studies of
deuteron spin/-lattice relaxation/. Con trarily to protonNMR sp ectra/, the deuteron sp ectra sho w without an yspin decoupling tec hnique man yw ell/-resolv ed line dou/-blets/, whic h can b e assigned to non/-equiv alen t siteson the molecule/. /#5B/1/7 /#5DA t presen ti t w as not y et at/-tained enough signal qualit y and resolution to separatethe corresp onding relaxation times for all the observ eddoublets/, due to the unfa v orably smaller gyromagneticratio /#28a higher detection /#0Celd is needed/#29/. Nev erthe/-less/, it is p ossible to measure the spin lattice relaxation
rates for some a v erage spin p ositions/, namely for thering windo w and the c hain windo w as sho wn in Fig/./6/. It is in teresting to note that/, while the disp ersionpro/#0Cle of the c hain deuterons rev eal an appro ximatesquare/-ro ot la w in the same frequency range than theproton data/, the rings deuterons exhibit a w eak fre/-quency dep endence/. This fact can b e qualitativ ely un/-dersto o d b y realizing that/, since the relev an t orien ta/-tion for quadrup olar coupling is the angle b et w een thecarb on/-h ydrogen b ond and the static magnetic /#0Celd/,the con tribution from the molecular rotations alongthe long axis of the molecule is signi/#0Ccan tly greater fordeuteron than for proton spin relaxation/./#5B/1/7 /#5DFinally /, in Fig/. /6 w e also sho w a comparison b e/-t w een proton T/1 Z
of the nematic /5CB /#28/4/- cy ano/-/4/' /-/5/-alkylbiphen yl/#29 and the alkyl c hain deuteron T/1 Z
for thep er/-deuterated nematic /5 CB /, d/1/9
/. As can b een clearlyseen the collectiv e motions dominate in coinciden t fre/-quency ranges/.IV Dip olar order relaxationField Cycling exp erimen ts are able to rev eal the fre/-quency range where co op erativ e motions dominate re/-laxation as w ell as giving an appro ximate v alue for therelativ ew eigh t of the di/#0Beren t relaxation mec hanismsin a n um b er of nematics and smectics/.The NMR proton sp ectra of liquid crystals generallypresen t unresolv ed broad lines/, due to the strong dip o/-lar in teractions/. The measured relaxation times repre/-sen t all spins in the molecule/, and the con tributions tothe sp ectral densities from di/#0Beren t kinds of sites aresup erimp osed/. When the molecular motions are com/-plex/, T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 alone is insu/#0Ecien t for disen tangling the
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/2/3di/#0Beren t con tributions to the sp ectral densities/. Thenit w ould b e adequate to complemen t the data of Zee/-man relaxation with another exp erimen t/. Under theassumption that the /#28w eak order/#29 form ulae from T a/-ble I hold in the whole frequency range/, measuring thefrequency dep endence of di/#0Beren t relaxation times/, lik eT/1 D
/#28or T/1 Q
/#29 together with T/1 Z
comes out to b e a moredescriptiv e exp erimen t/. The sp ectral densit y J
/1/#28 /#17 /#29 canb e directly determined through the /#0Crst one and then/,
b y using it in the form ula for the latter/, J
/2/#28/2 /#17 /#29 can b ecalculated/.
Figure /6/. Comparison of the frequency dep endence of T/1 Zin protons of /5CB /#28triangles/#29/, c hain deuterons of /5CB/- d/1/9/#28op en squares/#29 and ring deuterons only /#28circles/#29/. Deuteronmeasuremen ts allo w to select a separate frequency windo wfor di/#0Beren t sites in the molecule/. Data from Ref/. /1/7/.The /#0Crst step in this direction w as the /#0Celd cyclingmeasuremen t of b oth proton T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 and T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29i n afamily of thermotropic nematic liquid crystals/./#5B/2/8 /, /4/0/#5DThis metho d for measuring T/1 D
com bines the /#0Celdcycling tec hnique with the Jeener/-Bro ek aert pulse se/-quence for creating dip olar order/. Figs/. /#28/1b/#29 and /#28/1c/#29
sho w a diagram of the tec hnique/. Fig/. /#28/3/#29 sho wsthe disp ersion of T/1 D
and T/1 Z
in the nematic phaseof HpAB/. The /#0Crst outstanding feature is that T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29follo ws the t ypical trend of the OFD in the whole fre/-quency range /#28ev en for /#17 /#1D /1/0 MHz/!/#29/. This b eha vioris v ery di/#0Beren t from that of T/1 Z
where/, as a rule/, theOFD dominate/, at most up to h undreds of kilohertz/.Another in teresting feature is the o ccurrence of a cut/-o/#0B frequency ab out /5 /#02 /1/0
/4Hz/, whic h is an order ofmagnitude higher than the one of Zeeman relaxation
time/.The t w o/-spin mo del for dip olar relaxation /#28see T a/-ble /1/#29 predicts that T/1 Z
/=T/1 D
/#14 /3o v er all the frequency
range/, since the sp ectral densities are p ositiv e quan ti/-ties/. Con v ersely /, the exp erimen ts sho w that this ratiois greater than three in b oth HpAB and /8CB/, as dis/-pla y ed in Fig/. /7/. Also/, as can b e seen in Fig/. /8/, there isa noticeable gap b et w een the T/1 D
calculated with theisolated phen yl spin pairs mo del and the exp erimen taldata/; the di/#0Berence is frequency dep enden t and pro/-p ortional to /#17
/, /1 /= /2/,e v en at high frequencies/. Similarc haracteristics w ere found in other sev eral comp oundsin the nematic phase/, /#5B/2/9/,/4/0/#5D where it w as realized thatthe gap increases with the size of the molecule/.
Figure /7/. The quotien t T/1 Z
/=T/1 D
as a function of the Lar/-mor frequency in the nematic phase of HpAB and /8CB/.This ratio exceeds the v alue of three in discrepancy withthe semiclassical t w o/-spins mo del/. Data from Ref/./2/8/.As can b e seen in Fig/./#28/3/#29/, the con tribution fromthe OFD to T/1 Z
deca ys rapidly for increasing external/#0Celd/, and it generally b ecomes comparable to the sp ec/-
tral densities of rotational and translational di/#0Busion
for frequencies higher than /5 /#02 /1/0
/5Hz/. The situation israther di/#0Beren t for dip olar relaxation/, since it is mainlydriv en b y the OFD mec hanism even at high /#0Celds/. Itcan b e clearly appreciated in Fig/./#28/3/#29 the larger in/#0Duence
of the OFD as compared with the molecular rotationaldi/#0Busion/. It can b e a/#0Ermed that the rotations are prac/-tically negligible in T/1 D
/.These exp erimen tal /#0Cndings are c hallenging sincethey clearly p oin t out some de/#0Cciencies of the existen ttheoretical approac h/, but/, also rev eal T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29 as a mag/-nitude that re/#0Dects the OFD almost exclusiv ely in thea v ailable frequency range/.The fact that T/1 Z
/=T/1 D
/#15 /3 indicates that the ob/-serv ed dip olar order relaxation is faster than the onepredicted b y the traditional mo del/. On the con trary
/3/2/4 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29i s w ell describ ed b y the form ula from T ableIi n n umerous liquid crystals in the high /#0Celd limit/#28 H/0
/#3E/#3E Hlocal
/#29/./#5B/2 /,/3 /,/3 /1 /,/3 /2 /,/4 /9 /#5D Therefore/, the fail/-ure w as assigned /#5B/2/8 /#5D to the standard t w o/-spin /#28phen yl/#29approac h for dip olar order spin/-lattice relaxation rate/.
Figure /8/. F requency dep endence of the dip olar order re/-laxation in the nematic phase of HpAB and /8CB/. Thefull line corresp onds to the prediction from the t w o/-spinmo del and the dashed line is the b est /#0Ct with the functionT
/, /1/1 D
/=/3 CD
J
/1/#28 /#17 /#29intr a
/+ a/#17
/1 /= /2/+ b /. Data from Ref/./2/8/.It should b e k ept in mind that the usual mo del fordip olar relaxation in thermotropic liquid crystals/#5B/1/4/,
/5/0/#5D starts from the w eak order master equation /#5BEq/./#28/9/#29/#5Dand considers the spin system as an ensem ble of isolatedspin pairs/. Only in tramolecular con tributions are k ept/,arguing that the rapid di/#0Busiv e molecular motion a v/-erages out the in termolecular con tribution/. The c hainprotons are not considered either/, due to their high mo/-bilit y /. Another imp ortan th yp othesis is the one kno wnas /`fast motion/'/, that is /#17D
/#1Cc
/#1C /1/#28 /#17D
at ypical dip o/-lar frequency and /#1Cc
a lattice correlation time/#29/. Thiscondition allo ws to neglect the spin/-spin in teractions incalculating the time ev olution of the spin op erators inthe in teraction picture/. /#5B/5/#5DThe observ ed frequency dep enden t gap b et w een the/-ory and exp erimen tal data indicates that the mo delfor T/1 D
in liquid crystals is o v ersimpli/#0Ced and has ne/-glected imp ortan t mec hanisms of relaxation/, driv en b ythe OFD/. F or instance/, k eeping only t w o spins a v oids
the presence of sp ectral densities ev aluated at zero fre/-quency or frequencies of the order of magnitude of thedip olar coupling/, J
/0/#28 /#17D
/#29/, b ecause the co e/#0Ecien ts asso/-ciated to these terms in v olv e spin traces whic h are iden/-tically zero for t w o spins/. The ph ysical reason of thisis that these co e/#0Ecien ts represen t /`/#0Dip/-/#0Dop/' transitions/,that do not in v olv ec hanges in the dip olar energy of onlyt w o spins/. Also sp ectral densities with q /=/2 /, J
/2/#28/2 /#17 /#29/,do not app ear due to similar reasons/. According tothe proton sp ectra in nematics/, there is an appreciabledip olar con tact among the core and c hain protons/, giv/-ing the p ossibilit y of some e/#0Bects asso ciated to in terpairin teractions/. This imp oses a revision of the v alidit yo fthe h yp othesis in v olv ed in the mo del for dip olar relax/-ation/.A partial answ er came after a recen t exp erimen/-tal and theoretical in v estigation of T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 and T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29in P AA and in the meth yl/-deuterated P AAd /6
/./#5B/2/9 /,/5 /1 /#5DDeuterating the meth yl c hain yields a proton systemre/#0Decting only the dynamics of the c or e /. The frequencydep endence of the relaxation times in b oth comp ounds
sho w ed discrepancies with the t w o/-spin theory /, similarto those previously observ ed in HpAB and /8CB/. Fig/./#28/9/#29 sho ws the obtained results for the frequency dep en/-dence of T/1 Z
and T/1 D
at /1/3/0
/0C/. The /#0Cgures also includea plot of the underestimated dip olar relaxation rate as
giv en b yT able /1/. The exp erimen tal data of the dip olarrelaxation time can b e w ell represen ted b y the functionT
/, /1/1 D
/=/3 CD
J
/1/#28 /#17 /#29intr a
/+ a/#17
/, /1 /= /2/+ b /,d o wn to /1/0
/5Hz/.The /#0Crst correction term has the w ell kno wn frequencydep endence of the OFD/, /#5B/1/2 /#5D and the parameter a is/5 /: /3 /#02 /1/0
/3s
/, /3 /= /2and /4 /#02 /1/0
/3s
/, /3 /= /2for PA A and PA Ad /6
/,resp ectiv ely /. The frequency indep enden t term is relatedto the sp ectral densities with q /= /0 whic h app ear if themo del of isolated spin pairs is abandoned/. In this case/,the constan t are mainly asso ciated to the dip olar in ter/-action b et w een the c hain and the core/. This term is notdominan t/#28 b /=/0 /: /7 /#02 s
/, /1for PA A and b /=/0 /: /2 s
/, /1forPA Ad /6
/#29/, and con tribute appreciably only in the MH zrange/. F or instance/, at /1/0 MH z /, the constan t term rep/-resen ts the /7/#25 of the total relaxation rate for PA Ad /6
/.In relation with the theory /, follo wing the lines ofthe semiclassical formalism of spin/-lattice relaxation/#5B/5 /#5Da general high /#0Celd expression for T
/, /1/1 D
in nematic liq/-uid crystals v alid for an arbitrary n um b er of spins w as
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/2/5deduced giving the result/: /#5B/2/9 /#5DcT
/, /1/1 D
/= T
/, /1/1 D cor r
/+
/2/7 /#0D
/4/~
/2/8 N
Plk
J
/1lk
/#28 /#17 /#29
F
/0lk
/2Pj
F
/0lj
/2
/+
/4 /#0D
/4/~
/2/3 N
Pj
F
/0lj
/2
Plk
Pq
J
qlk
/#28 /#17q /#29 /#02na
q
Pm /6/= k
/#10F
/0lm
/2/+ F
/0km
/2
/#11/+ b
q
Pm /6/= k
F
/0lm
F
/0km
o/;
/#28/1/6/#29d
Figure /9/: Zeeman and dip olar relaxation rates/, measuredwith the /#0Celd cycling tec hnique in nematic PA A and ne/-matic P AAd /6
at the same temp erature/. The circles andsquares are exp erimen tal T/1
and T/1 D
resp ectiv ely /. The up/-p er full lines are the /#0Ctting to T/1 Z
with T able I and Eq/./#28/1/1/#29/.The dashed lines are the semiclassical t w o/-spin mo del forT/1 D
from T able I/. The lo w er full lines are the b est /#0Cts withthe function T
/, /1/1 D
/=/3 CD
J
/1/#28 /#17 /#29intr a
/+ a/#17
/1 /= /2/+ b /#28see the text/#29/.Data from Ref/./2/9/.The /#0Crst term corresp onds to in terpair cross corre/-lations/, while the others in v olv e uncorrelated in terac/-tions/. All terms ha v e similar structure/: they are pro/-p ortional to angular a v erages of the t yp e F
/0lj
/2/. Thein termolecular con tributions cancel due to the rapid rel/-ativ e motion of the molecule/. Accordingly /, the transla/-tional self/-di/#0Busion do es not con tribute appreciably todip olar order relaxation in nematics/.This general result allo ws to in v estigate the roleof in terpair correlation of protons of the core and thec hains/. When particularized to P AAd /6
for calculatingthe con tribution to T/1 D
b y including second neigh bo r
protons/, the calculation yielded a negligible correctionto the usual t w o/-spin prediction/. This fact/, whic hi sconsequence of the r
/, /3dep endence of the dip olar en/-ergy in teraction/, is consisten t with NMR line shap esecond/-momen t studies/#5B/5/2/#5D that c haracterize P AAd /6
asat w o/-spin system/.According to the former results/, the dip olar orderrelaxation of P AAd /6
/, although seeming to b e a t w o/-spinproblem/, cannot b e describ ed b y the usual form ula forisolated spin pairs/!/. This means that the observ ed gaphas to b e asso ciated to some other t yp e of pro cesseswhic h are not considered b y this approac h/.A p oin t still requiring discussion is the fast motionh yp othesis/, con tained in the basic w eak/-order theory /.T ec hnically /, this amoun ts to calculating the ev olutionof the spin op erators in the in teraction picture with theop erator exp
it/= /~ HZ/#28a simple rotation around the direc/-tion of the magnetic /#0Celd/#29/. F or the slo w est comp onen tsof the OFD the condition /#17D
/#1Cc
/#1C /1 is not ful/#0Clled/; thenneglecting the spin in teractions during the lifetime ofthe /#0Ductuations ma y b e inadequate/. In suc h cases/, thetime ev olution has to b e calculated using the completeop erator e
it/= /~ /#28 HZ
/+ HD
/#29in order to the in tro duce the in/-teractions/. Ho w ev er/, this correction to the standard ap/-proac h did not in tro duce signi/#0Ccan tc hanges either/./#5B/3/0 /#5DThat is/, this pro cedure do es not lead to a frequency de/-p enden t correction as needed for explaining the T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29disp ersion/.The insensibilit y sho wn b y the w eak/-order result tothe inclusion of the spin in teractions in the microscopictime scale/, can b e in terpreted as follo ws/: As sho wn inSection I I/, the w eak order master equation is obtainedb y neglecting terms of quan tum mec hanical c haracterin Eq/./#28/8/#29/. The relaxation rates calculated in this limitare formally equiv alen t to those calculated directly from
/3/2/6 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8a sto c hastic Liouville equation/, where the lattice v ari/-ables of the spin/-lattice Hamiltonian are giv en randomtime functions/. By represen ting the lattice v ariableswith arbitrary random functions of time/, the bac k/-reaction of the lattice on the spin system during the
lifetime of the /#0Ductuations cannot b e retained/.In summary /, the former example allo ws to safelyconclude that the w eak/-order theory do es not con tainall the ingredien ts necessary to explain the dip olar or/-der relaxation in systems ha ving slo w /#0Ductuations/, lik enematic thermotropics/. According to this outstanding
conclusion/, the failure m ust b e sough t in the v ery basicassumptions of the w eak/-order relaxation theory /.In order to include the correlation b et w een a manyb o dy system and the lattic e in the micr osc opic timesc ale /, it is necessary to k eep the quan tum terms ofEq/./#28/8/#29/. Namely /, when dealing with the relaxation ofthe dip olar order/, the spin system should b e treated
as an op en quan tum system in thermal con tact with aquan tum mec hanical lattice/. This can b e done b y elim/-inating the w eak/-order assumption/./#5B/3/0 /, /5/3/#5D Under thisgeneral condition/, the master equation in the form of
Eq/./#28/8/#29 is not easily applicable to the calculation of thetime dep endence of spin observ ables/. A more tractableequation follo ws b y p erforming a series expansion of themaster equation in op erator form/./#5B/5/4 /#5D The lo w est orderterm of the expansion coincides with the /#0Crst term ofEq/./#28/8/#29/, while the higher order ones represen t the quan/-tum mec hanical part/. In fact/, the new con tributionscancel if the lattice is represen ted b y a sto c hastic pro/-cess/. The formalism is/, at this p oin t/, adequate for in/-tro ducing a /`trial/' solution/. The trial densit y op eratorcommonly used in NMR is the one corresp onding to the
spin temp erature assumption/. Ph ysically /, it consists inassuming that the relaxation can b e describ ed as a suc/-cession of semi/-equilibrium states/./#5B/5/5/, /5/6/#5D Doing this/,it is straigh tforw ard to calculate a relaxation time interms of the sp ectral densities/./#5B/3/0/#5DUsing the Pincus/-Blinc mo del for the nematic h y/-dro dynamic motions/, leads to a correction term to the
usual expression of the dip olar order relaxation rate/,ha ving the form a/#17
/, /1 /= /2/. This result agrees with thephenomenological expression used in /#0Ctting P AAd /6
andP AA data/, and other thermotropic nematic liquid crys/-tals/. Accordingly /, the discrepancy b et w een exp erimen tsand the w eak order theory can b e explained in terms
of m ultispin pro cesses ha ving a quan tum mec hanicalc haracter/.The existence of the anomalous lo w/-frequency cut/-o/#0B can also b e discussed in terms of the quan tum me/-c hanical approac h/. When the external magnetic /#0Celdis lo w ered so that the Larmor frequency is comparablewith the linewidth /#28/1/0
/5Hz/#29/, the description is made interms of the dip olar and not the Zeeman energy lev els/.Under this condition the Larmor frequency ceases to b ea collectiv e parameter of the spin system/.V Final comm e n tsF requency dep enden t T/1 Z
exp erimen ts using the /#0Celdcycling tec hnique ha v e sho wn useful in c haracterizingthe OFD/. This is sp ecially clear in nematics/, where thet ypical frequency b eha vior dominates in a broad fre/-quency range and less eviden t in smectics/. The factthat smectics ha v e slo w er lo cal molecular motions thannematics has a double e/#0Bect in reducing the e/#0Bectiv e/-ness of T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29 for displa ying unam biguously the con/-tribution of the collectiv e motions/. On the one handindividual molecular motions /#28rotation and di/#0Busion/#29ha v e a greater relativ ew eigh t in smectics/. On the other/,the frequency dep endence of the OFD is steep er/. This
amoun ts in a narro wing of the frequency range wherethe OFD dominate relaxation /#5Bsee Fig/./#28/4/#29/#5D/.Due to the strong spin/-spin in teraction/, the protonZeeman relaxation time is an a v erage parameter repre/-sen ting all the protons placed in di/#0Beren t kind of sites/#28for example in the c hain or the core/#29/. In moleculesha ving man y protons this pro duces a certain degree ofam biguit y in the ph ysical parameters obtained from the/#0Cttings/, due to the large n um b er of parameters thatha v e to b e determined/. More informativ en uclei w ouldb e deuterons /#28D/#29 or carb ons /#28
/1/3C/#29 b ecause they sepa/-rate individual atomic sites on the molecules b y a gen/-erally w ell/-resolv ed sp ectrum/. Ho w ev er/, suc h exp eri/-men ts imply imp ortan t tec hnological di/#0Eculties/. Thislimitati on can b e partially eliminated/, in a more ac/-cessible w a yb y com bining exp erimen ts of relaxation inprotons of partially deuterated molecules/; so doing the
di/#0Beren t relaxation mec hanisms can b e separated b y al/-ternativ ely deuterating the c hains or the cores/. Also/,these exp erimen ts can b e complemen ted with angular
R/.C/. Zamar et al/. /3/2/7dep enden t measuremen ts/, whic h pro vide additional ex/-p erimen tal information /#5B/1/4 /, /2/2/, /5/7 /#5DIn Section /#28IV/#29 w e sho w ed some examples wheredip olar order relaxation re/#0Dects the OFD almost exclu/-
siv ely /. This outstanding feature mak es T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29 an opti/-m um parameter for studying slo w collectiv e molecularmotion in mesophases/. Accordingly /, it could b e help/-ful for testing theoretical mo dels for the h ydro dynamic/#0Ductuations in mesophases ha ving di/#0Beren t dimension/-alit y /.Due to the di/#0Beren t frequency resp onse of b oth re/-laxation times/, exp erimen ts of T/1 D
/#28 /#17 /#29 in conjunctionwith T/1 Z
/#28 /#17 /#29m a y pro vide v aluable exp erimen tal to olsfor the study of molecular motions in mesophases/. P ar/-ticularly /,i t w ould allo w to clearly discern the frequencydep endence of the collectiv e motions in smectics/. Ho w/-ev er/, for these studies to b e fruitful/, a thorough the/-oretical revision of the e/#0Bect of the slo w /#0Ductuationsof the director on the dip olar relaxation rate b ecomes
necessary /, since a comprehensiv e expression of T
/, /1/1 D
interms of sp ectral densities is still lac king/.P arallel to the /#0Celd of the applications/, from a basicp ersp ectiv e/, dip olar order relaxation also pro vides anin teresting example of irrev ersible pro cesses where thespin/-spin in teractions o ccurring during the microscopictime in terv als seem to pro duce observ able e/#0Bects in thetransp ort parameters/.VI Ac kno wledgm en tW e are grateful to Dr/. D/. J/. Pusiol for helpful discus/-sions/. This w ork w as partially supp orted b y CONICORand SECYT from C/#13 ordoba/, CONICET and F undaci/#13 onAn torc has from Argen tina/. The authors dedicate thepresen tw ork to the memory of Prof/. F/. Noac k whomade imp ortan t con tributions to the /#0Celd of NMR inmesophases/.References/#5B/1/#5D A/.Abragam/, The Principles of Nucle ar MagneticR esonanc e /#28 Oxford U/.P /. London /1/9/6/1/#29/, Chap/. VI I I/./#5B/2/#5D R/.Y/. Dong/, Nucle ar Magnetic R esonanc e of LiquidCrystals /#28Heidelb erg/, Springer/, /1/9/9/4/#29/./#5B/3/#5D F/. Noac k/, M/. Notter/, and W/. Wiess/, Liq/. Cryst/. /3 /,/9/0/7 /#28/1/9/8/8/#29/./#5B/4/#5D J/.M/.Deutc h and I/. Opp enheim/, Adv/. in MagneticResonance/, /3 /, /4/3 /#28/1/9/6/8/#29/.
/#5B/5/#5D J/. Jeener/, Adv ances in Magnetic Resonance /3 /, /2/0/5/#28/1/9/6/8/#29/./#5B/6/#5D M/. Vilfan and S/. Zumer/, Ph ys/. Rev/. A /1/7 /, /4/2/4/,/#28/1/9/7/8/#29/./#5B/7/#5D M/. Vilfan and S/. Zumer/, Ph ys/. Rev/. A /2/1 /, /6/7/2/#28/1/9/8/0/#29/./#5B/8/#5D D/. W o essner/, J/. Chem/. Ph ys/. /3/7 /, /6/4/7 /#28/1/9/6/2/#29/./#5B/9/#5D P /. DeGennes and J/. Prost/, The Physics of Liq/-uid Crystals /2 nd Edition /#28Oxford/, Clarendon Press/,/1/9/9/3/#29/./#5B/1/0/#5D J/.H/. F reed/, J/.Chem/. Ph ys/. /6/6 /, /4/1/8/3 /#28/1/9/7/7/#29/./#5B/1/1/#5D G/.P /. Zien tara and J/.H/. F reed/, J/. Chem/. Ph ys/. /7/9 /,/3/0/7/7 /#28/1/9/8/3/#29/./#5B/1/2/#5D P /. Pincus/, Solid State Comm un/. /7 /, /4/1/5 /#28/1/9/6/9/#29/./#5B/1/3/#5D R/. Blinc/, D/. L/. Hogen b o om/, D/. E/. O/'Reilly /, and E/.M/. P eterson/, Ph ys/. Rev/. Lett/. /2/3 /, /1/7/, /9/6/9 /#28/1/9/6/9/#29/./#5B/1/4/#5D R/. Blinc/, M/. Luzar/, M/. Vilfan and M/. Burgar/, J/.Chem/. Ph ys/. /6/3 /#28/8/#29/, /3/4/4/5 /#28/1/9/7/5/#29/./#5B/1/5/#5D M/. Vilfan/, M/. Kogo j and R/. Blinc/, J/. Chem/. Ph ys/./8/6 /, /1/0/5/5 /#28/1/9/8/7/#29/./#5B/1/6/#5D K/.H/. Sc h w eik ert and F/. Noac k/, Mol/. Crys/. Liq/. Crys/./2/1/2 /, /3/3 /#28/1/9/9/2/#29/./#5B/1/7/#5D R/. K/#7F ollner/, K/.H/. Sc h w eik ert/, and F/. Noac k/, Liq/.Cryst/. /1/3 /, /#28/4/#29 /4/8/3 /#28/1/9/9/3/#29/./#5B/1/8/#5D W/. Kuhner/, E/. Rommel/, F/. Noac k and P /. Meier/, Z/.Naturforsc h/./, /4/2a /, /1/2/7 /#28/1/9/8/7/#29/./#5B/1/9/#5D T/. Mugele/, V/. Graf/, W/. W/#7F olfel/, F/. Noac k/, Z/. Natur/-forsc h/, /3/5a /, /9/2/4 /#28/1/9/7/7/#29/./#5B/2/0/#5D E/. Rommel/, F/. Noac k/, P /. Meier and G/. Kothe/, J/.Ph ys/. Chem/. /9/2 /, /2/9/8/1 /#28/1/9/8/8/#29/./#5B/2/1/#5D J/. Strupp e/, F/. Noac k and G/. Klose/, Z/. Naturforsc h/./5/2 a /, /6/8/1 /#28/1/9/9/7/#29/./#5B/2/2/#5D J/. Strupp e and F/. Noac k/, Liq/. Cryst/. /2/0 /, /5/9/5/-/6/0/6/#28/1/9/9/6/#29/./#5B/2/3/#5D K/. Blum/, Density Matrix The ory and Applic ation s /,/#28Plen um Press/, New Y ork/, /1/9/8/1/#29/./#5B/2/4/#5D A/. G/. Red/#0Celd/, Adv/. Mag/. Res/. I /, p/./1 /#28/1/9/6/5/#29/./#5B/2/5/#5D J/.P /. Jacobsen/, H/.K/. Bildso e and K/. Sc haum burg/, J/.Magn/. Res/. /2/3 /, /1/5/3 /#28/1/9/7/6/#29/./#5B/2/6/#5D H/.W/. Spiess/, J/. Chem/. Ph ys/. /7/2 /, /6/7/5/5 /#28/1/9/8/0/#29/./#5B/2/7/#5D J/. Jeneer and P /. Bro ek aert/, Ph ys/.Rev /1/5/7 /, /2/3/2/#28/1/9/6/7/#29/./#5B/2/8/#5D R/. Zamar/, E/. Anoardo/, O/. Mensio/, D/. Pusiol/, S/.Bec k er and F/. Noac k/, J/. Chem/. Ph ys/. /1/0/9 /, /3/, /1/1/2/0/#28/1/9/9/8/#29/./#5B/2/9/#5D O/. Mensio/, R/.C/. Zamar/, D/.J/. Pusiol and S/. Bec k er/,/#28submitted/#29/./#5B/3/0/#5D R/.C/. Zamar and/, O/. Mensio/, /#28unpublished /#29/./#5B/3/1/#5D Nucle ar Magnetic R esonanc e of Liquid Crystalsedited b y J/.W/. Emsley /#28NA TO ASI Series/, /1/9/8/5/#29/./#5B/3/2/#5D R/.L/. V old/, W/.H/. Dic k erson and R/.R/. V old/, J/. Mag/.Reson/. /4/3 /, /2/1/3/, /#28/1/9/8/1/#29/.
/3/2/8 Brazilian Journal of Ph ysics/, v ol/. /2/8/, no/. /4/, Decem b er/, /1/9/9/8/#5B/3/3/#5D R/.R/. V old and R/. L/. V old/, J/. Chem Ph ys/. /8/8 /, /1/4/4/3/#28/1/9/8/7/#29/./#5B/3/4/#5D J/.W/. Doane/, J/.J/. Visin tainer/, Ph ys/. Rev/. Lett/. /2/3 /,/1/4/2/1 /#28/1/9/6/9/#29/./#5B/3/5/#5D M/. W eger and B/. Cabane/, J/. Ph ys/. /3/0 /, C/4/-/7/2 /#28/1/9/6/9/#29/./#5B/3/6/#5D M/. Vilfan/, R/. Blinc/, and J/. W/. Doane/, Solid St/.Comm un/. /1/1 /, /1/0/7/3 /#28/1/9/7/2/#29/./#5B/3/7/#5D F/. Noac k/, in Encyclop ae dia of NMR /, edited b y D/.M/.Gran t and R/.K/. Harris/, Wiley /, New Y ork/, pp /1/9/8/0/-/1/9/9/0 /#28/1/9/9/5/#29/./#5B/3/8/#5D V/. Graf/, F/. Noac k and M/. Stohrer/, Z/. Naturforsc h/./3/2a /, /6/1 /#28/1/9/7/7/#29/./#5B/3/9/#5D W/, W/#7F olfel/, F/. Noac k/, M/. Stohrer/, Z/. Naturforsc h/3/0a /, /4/3/7 /#28/1/9/7/5/#29/./#5B/4/0/#5D S/.A/. Bec k er/, Thesis /,P h ysik alisc hes Institut der Uni/-v ersit/#7F at Stuttgart/, /#28/1/9/9/6/#29/./#5B/4/1/#5D R/. Blinc/, NMR Summer Sc ho ol/, W aterlo o/, p/./9/7/#28/1/9/7/5/#29/./#5B/4/2/#5D M/. Notter/, Diplomarb eit /,P h ysik alis c hes Institut derUniv ersit/#7F at Stuttgart/, /#28/1/9/8/6/#29/./#5B/4/3/#5D J/. Mager/, Thesis /,P h ysik alisc hes Institut der Uni/-v ersit/#7F at Stuttgart/, /#28/1/9/9/3/#29/./#5B/4/4/#5D F/. V aca Ch/#13 av ez and D/. J/. Pusiol/, /#5CXXI Encon troNacional de F /#13 /#10sica da Materia Condensada/"/, Ca/-xambu/, Brasil/, pag/. /1/7/9/, /#28/1/9/9/8/#29/./#5B/4/5/#5D D/. Pusiol and F/. Noac k/, Liq/. Crys/. /5 /, /3/7/7/, /#28/1/9/8/9/#29/.
/#5B/4/6/#5D D/. J/. Pusiol and R/. Acosta/, priv ate comm unication/./#5B/4/7/#5D P /. Zollino/, Diplomarb eit /,P h ysik alisc h es Institut derUniv ersit/#7F at Stuttgart/, /#28/1/9/9/2/#29/./#5B/4/8/#5D W/. K /#7F uner/, E/. Rommel/, F/. Noac k/, Z/. Naturforsc h/4/2a /, /1/2/7 /#28/1/9/8/6/#29/./#5B/4/9/#5D R/. Kimmic h/, T omo gr aphy/, Di/#0Busometry/, R elaxom/-etry /#28Berlin/, Springer/, /1/9/9/8/#29/./#5B/5/0/#5D R/.G/.C/. Mc/. Elro y /, R/.T/. Thompson and M/.M/. Pin/-tar/, Ph ys/. Rev/. A /1/0 /, /4/0/3 /#28/1/9/7/4/#29/./#5B/5/1/#5D O/. Mensio/, R/. C/. Zamar/, D/. J/. Pusiol and S/.Bec k er /`/1/3
thISMAR Satellite Meeting of the Am/-p ere Congress/'/, Berl /#13 /#10n/, Alemania /#28/1/9/9/8/#29/./#5B/5/2/#5D R/.Y/. Dong/, B/. Nakk a and E/. T omc h uk/, Mol/. Cryst/.Liq/. Cryst/. /3/8 /, /5/3 /#28/1/9/7/7/#29/./#5B/5/3/#5D O/. Mensio y R/.C/. Zamar/, Anales de la AF A/, v ol/. /8 /,/1/3/8 /#28/1/9/9/6/#29/./#5B/5/4/#5D O/. Mensio y R/. Zamar/, /#5C I I I W orkshop Ib eroamer/-icano de Fluidos Complejos y sus Aplicaciones/"/,Concep ci/#13 on/, Chile /#28/1/9/9/7/#29/./#5B/5/5/#5D M/. Goldman/, Spin T emp er atur e and Nucle ar Mag/-netic R esonanc e in Solids /#28P ergamon Press/, Oxford/1/9/7/9/#29/./#5B/5/6/#5D L/.C/. Heb el/, Solid/. St/. Ph ys/. /1/5 /, /4/0/9 /#28/1/9/6/3/#29/./#5B/5/7/#5D R/.Y/. Dong and J/. Sandeman/, J/. Chem/. Ph ys/. /7/8 /,/4/6/4/9 /#28/1/9/8/3/#29/.